November 24, 2006

The Golden Egg “Is Silver Now”

The Denver Post reports from Colorado. “Farm fields around the metro area are selling more slowly these days as national builders scramble to sell new homes they’ve already built, buyers and sellers involved in the transactions say.”

“For example, Brighton-area developer Craig Carlson said he recently dropped an option to purchase an 800-acre parcel south of Brighton after working on the transaction since 2000. Melody Homes, a division of national homebuilder DR Horton, walked away from a rumored $1 million that the company spent on plans and development issues on a parcel east of Longmont earlier this year.”

“KB Homes is one homebuilder that’s treading carefully in the more volatile market, said Rusty Crandall, the company’s division president in Denver. ‘We are being very careful about making any large investments and where we have our land acquisitions, we’re only buying those parcels that fit our strategy perfectly,’ Crandall said.”

“Farm-field sales are worse in states like California, Nevada and Florida than in Colorado, Carlson said, because new home prices shot up in those states even more quickly than they did here, and now…prices are dropping across the country.”

“Earlier in the year, property owner Jim Anderson sold more than 500 acres east of Longmont before the slowdown started in earnest. ‘We did close, even though some people did walk away (earlier),’ Anderson said.”

“With home foreclosures near record levels, banks are looking for alternatives such as online auctions to sell their properties. Freddie Mac listed four foreclosed properties with agent Roger Bottoms. When the properties failed to sell quickly, Freddie Mac decided to list them on (an) online auction site.”

“‘Only one has sold,’ Bottoms said. ‘If the banks had lowered the prices in the first place, they would have gotten more out of the properties and not wasted their time on an auction.’”

“Mortgage companies faced with an increasing number of delinquencies will do what it takes to reduce their inventory. ‘Our interest is in making the sale and getting a good market price to reduce our own credit losses, as well as creating an affordable homeownership opportunity,’ said Brad German, a spokesman for Freddie Mac.”

“During September, 4,485 Colorado properties were in some stage of foreclosure.

The Billings Gazette from Montana. “‘For sale’ signs are sprouting like weeds in the suburbs of Phoenix and Las Vegas, and foreclosures are way up in Colorado and Georgia. But as 2006 winds down, Billings real estate experts say the local market has avoided the ’speculative bubble’ that was real estate’s worry last year as well as the steep downturn in prices that many areas of the country saw this year.”

“The current rate of increase is well short of the double-digit price gains the Billings housing market experienced in 2004 and 2005. ‘Billings doesn’t have the sex appeal of some markets, but if you want a good solid return on your investment, it does provide that,’ said said Howard Sumner, a Billings real estate agent who closely tracks local real estate trends.”

“Ann Adair, economist at Montana State University-Billings, said economic indicators point to some softening in the Billings real estate market, but there’s little cause for concern. ‘It’s not anything huge,’ Adair said. ‘Sales appear to be in pretty good shape. There’s nothing huge and significant and scary.’”

“‘The traffic on our new houses and open houses has been very strong,’ (realtor) Rick Dorn said. ‘If you didn’t have people circulating, there would have been some nervousness.’”

“The number of houses on the market has increased by a larger amount. According to figures compiled by Sumner, 1,018 residential properties are for sale, compared with 864 at this time last year.”

“One reason houses are on the market longer is that some sellers may be pricing too aggressively, said Frosty Erben, president of the Billings Association of Realtors.”

“‘Because of what the selling public has read or heard, they may have an unrealistic view of the value of their home, and the tendency is to price it above what the market is,’ he said. ‘People want to turn their house into the goose that laid the golden egg, when the egg is silver now,’ Erben said.”

“‘Things are a lot better here than if you watch the national news,’ said Sam Picard, president of the Home Builders Association of Billings. ‘That’s not to say we’re where we were a year or a year and a half ago.’”




RSS feed | Trackback URI

27 Comments »

Comment by boulderbo
2006-11-24 10:53:39

attended the auction in denver on saturday this past week, rural homes on the front range went for $50-60k. having lent on these properties over the last four years, i can tell you that these properties were purchased for $150-175k minimum. this was the first of many auctions to come. even at 50 cents on the dollar, i thought that the buyers were catching a falling knife.

Comment by Markmax33
2006-11-24 10:55:47

Awesome! What town was that?

Comment by boulderbo
2006-11-24 10:59:53

fort lupton, greeley, fort collins, aurora, etc. even in denver metro, most homes sold for well below $100k. two years ago you couldn’t find a single family below $150k in the metro area, even in the hood. greeley seems to be particularly bad, foreclosure numbers are over the top out there, helped by speculative home building.

Comment by crash1
2006-11-24 11:31:01

The other day I took Hwy 52 from I-25 to the Diagonal trying to find a new shortcut. I was amazed how many rural properties were for sale. A lot of them are in what I remember to be farm fields. Seems like most are little ranchettes on 5 acre or smaller lots, but I saw signs for most of the big builders too. I bet some of those homes could be hard to sell after the rural living thing wears off.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
 
 
 
Comment by Tango in Uniform
2006-11-24 11:05:25

boulderbo,

Since the area didn’t see huge appreciation, even with the high use of exotic loans, does it mean that the front range would have been crashing for years now if it were not for stupid loans?

Comment by boulderbo
2006-11-24 11:17:55

bingo, imho

 
 
 
Comment by Binko
2006-11-24 11:00:43

How about if the egg is iron now? A painfully heavy iron egg that will be weighing down your pocket for years to come.

People simply have a hard time grasping the fact that the free money through real estate frenzy is over. “OK”, they say, “so I accept that I’m not going to get filthy rich by selling any old crappy house anymore. How about if I still make a pile of money? I’ll settle for a slightly reduced pile of money but I still want my pile.”

I can never remember the saying about the five stages of grief. Or is it four stages? But, it’s pretty clear that most home owners are still in the bargaining stage. They are still a long way from accepting that it’s not a golden egg anymore, it’s not even a silver egg nor a bronze egg.

Comment by HARM
2006-11-24 11:13:34

You’re referring to the Kübler-Ross grief model:

The 5 stages are:

Denial - The “This can’t be real” stage.: “This is not happening to me.” “There must be a mistake”
Anger - The “Why me?” stage.: “How dare you do this to me?!” (either referring to God, the late person, or themselves)
Bargaining - The “If I do this, you’ll do that” stage.: “Just let me live to see my son graduate.”
Depression - The “Defeated” stage.: “I can’t bear to face going through this, putting my family through this.”
Acceptance - The “This is going to happen” stage.: “I’m ready, I don’t want to struggle anymore.”

Personally, I doubt most sellers are past “denial” and “anger” yet.

 
Comment by HARM
2006-11-24 11:21:51

2005 golden egg (peak of the bubble, I’m R-I-C-H, bi-yatchhh!!!!)
2006 silver egg (ARM resets just starting, prices levelling or modestly falling)
2007 lead egg (ARM resets topping $1 Trillion mark for first time, most cities in free-fall, specuvestors gone)
2008 fecal egg (ARM resets above $2 Trillion and rising, foreclosures at 15-year highs)
2009-2012 plutonium egg (housing completely toxic, foreclosures at all-time highs, real (inflation adjusted) prices finally bottom around 1997 levels)

Comment by libertas
2006-11-24 14:52:29

I think that’s about right

 
 
 
Comment by Houstonstan
2006-11-24 11:06:47

Is it just me but some of these RE people names crack me up.

“‘Only one has sold,’ Bottoms said. ‘If the banks had lowered the prices in the first place, they would have gotten more out of the properties and not wasted their time on an auction.’”

I guess this is what the mean when we’ve reached the Bottom of the market.

 
Comment by mugsy
2006-11-24 11:11:19

“On the other hand, most of the people using exotic loans (100% interest, option ARM, etc) would never be able to get a mortgage any other way. ”

Mikhail,

If this is the only way people can get a mortgage, maybe they shouldn’t be buying a house? Owning a home is not a right and if you can’t come up with the DP and closing costs you shouldn’t be acting like a land baron and financing 100%.

Comment by HARM
2006-11-24 11:54:19

No kidding… Complete unadulterated, self-serving REIC bullshit.

The main REASON why prices are so far out of line with rents and incomes today is becuase so many people (especially Carleton Sheets/Marshall Reddick amateur “investors”) are using this type of financing. If people weren’t borrowing insane amounts of funny money using unconventional mortgages they have zero chance of repaying, prices would never have been bid up to insane levels.

10 years ago, neg-ams, stated incomes and interest only loans were all but unheard of for people other than the very rich or self-employed. Working-class people purchased houses with conventional full-doc loans and –amazingly– housing was MUCH more affordable. Working class people today cannot buy a home with conventional financing BECAUSE they will be immediately outbid by some Casey Serin asshat who can now borrow $2.4 million in neg-am monopoly money.

The risk of losing the home later may be high to these people who are forced to use exotic loans (i.e. because they can’t afford, or qualify, for anything else), but if lenders are willing to lend money anyway, why not take advantage of it?

Hmmm…. I dunno…. maybe because I don’t want to commit mortgage fraud, lose my house in foreclosure, ruin my credit and possibly do jail time? Oh, wait, I forgot –it’s OK as long as “everyone is doing it”. Thanks for clearing that up!

Comment by Housing Wizard
2006-11-24 12:14:13

Nice summary Harm about how these jerks pushed the price of houses up . I have said it many times ……. speculators , flippers ,and unqualified loan borrowers are a false market demand because of the short term nature of their objectives ,along with their lack of ability to repay the debt .

Comment by Ben Jones
2006-11-24 12:48:30

Please don’t feed the troll.

(Comments wont nest below this level)
Comment by lefantome
2006-11-24 17:37:59

“Please don’t feed the troll….” ?

What did I miss?

 
 
 
 
 
Comment by Tango in Uniform
2006-11-24 11:16:18

According to the recent report, Montana posted one of the best YOY sales increases, while most states saw falling sales. Naturally Realtors think this means it’s different here. I think we’re just a lagging state.

Read the comments at the bottom of the Billings article. I was pleasantly surprised at how many residents saw through the spin.

Also, I posted this earlier this week, but I went to the newspaper archives then plotted out headlines and Realtor quotes against a price graph 1984-2006. Very telling to see the denial on the way down in the 80’s crash!

What did Realtors say last time?

Comment by 4shzl
2006-11-24 11:46:15

Does this mean you won’t be plunking down a deposit for a McMansion at Superfund Meadows? Scared of drinking water that glows in the dark? Well, Billings doesn’t need you, anyway — it’s for Marlboro men, not girly guys.

Boooowahahahahahahahahaha!

 
Comment by Conrad
2006-11-24 12:16:22

Very telling indeed. Good info keep up the good work!

 
 
Comment by Hubrispie
2006-11-24 11:30:45

The lie propagated concerning the Colorado market one year ago was that because Colorado did not have a run-up in prices over the last 5 years, there must be no bubble. The Montana story sounds eerily similar.

Comment by Tango in Uniform
2006-11-24 11:43:02

When did Colorado’s foreclosure rate begin to ramp up? Montana’s is still very low. But 33% of Montana’s subprime loans in 2005 were interest-only or pay-option, so that will probably be changing soon.

Comment by Hubrispie
2006-11-24 12:20:05

My recollection is that the foreclosure rate has been climbing every year since around 2001. It was poo-pooed for many years as a “lagging indicator” and due primarily to the high tech and telecommunication layoffs. The run-up in housing occurred from 1993-2001 and the last five years have been relatively stagnant largely because of easy credit, (otherwise housing would have collapsed here).

 
 
 
Comment by the_economist
2006-11-24 11:35:06

I drove up I75 thru central florida last week…I think the whole state is for sale.

 
Comment by jack
2009-07-24 05:46:36

When is Marshall Reddick going to jail. This guy seems to have pulled a major scam on your average middle class, getting them to think they could become millionaires by just buying real estate via the “arm chair investor” method. This guy instructed people to buy one house a year.

 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

Trackback responses to this post