Flat Home Prices Increase Subprime Payment Shock: Fitch
Some housing bubble news from Wall Street. “MFA Mortgage Investments today reported a net loss available to common stockholders of $32.6 million. Stewart Zimmerman, MFA’s Chairman said, ‘As previously indicated, increases in the target federal funds rate continue to increase the cost of MFA’s liabilities at a more rapid pace than the yield on its assets, negatively impacting spreads.”
“As a result of the Federal Reserve’s efforts to tighten monetary policy and the fact that, in general, the yields on MFA’s assets reset annually, but only after an initial fixed rate period, we anticipate that MFA will experience a period of reduced earnings over the next several quarters.’”
“Freddie Mac, still recovering from an accounting scandal, on Friday said it would delay by two months the release of its quarterly and full-year 2005 financial results to implement an accounting change. The company recently decided to make greater use of third-party market information in its method for valuing those assets.”
Speaking of third parties. “The current environment of deeply teased short-term U.S. subprime hybrid adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs), combined with an interest-only (IO) affordability feature, can lead to substantial payment shock at the ARM reset, according to a newly released criteria report by Fitch Ratings. As a result, Fitch is adjusting its treatment of IOs on two- and three-year subprime hybrid ARMs to reflect the higher odds of default.”
“Fitch analyzed the payment shock potential for 2005 subprime IO and non-IO ARM products and found that the payment increase for an IO at the rate reset is significantly larger than the increase from principal amortization and is high even if rates do not rise due to the high margins and low initial rates.”
“Subprime IO credit performance has been strong due to the favorable economic climate of the past few years. ‘However, newer vintages may not exhibit the same strong performance because more borrowers could face a payment increase as home price appreciation slows,’ said Grant Bailey, Director, Fitch Ratings.”
“Fitch believes that the 2004 borrowers who are rate resetting for the first time in 2006 are less likely to face this obstacle since home values rose between 2004 and 2006. Fitch believes that loans resetting in 2007 and later may be more susceptible to the payment shock risk.”
From the LA Times. “Japan’s audacious five-year experiment of force-feeding cash into an ailing economy began to wind down Thursday, chased into history by central bankers convinced that Japanese industry and consumers have risen from their sickbed and no longer need easy credit.”
“Some economists also worry that higher rates could have global repercussions by encouraging Japanese investors to repatriate some of their vast U.S. investment holdings. That could force the Federal Reserve to push up rates more steeply than they are already climbing, leading to higher U.S. mortgage costs and depressed housing prices.”
FYI,
I just got off the phone with Mr. Lansner. In order to more completely answer the many points brought up, he will have a reply to this blog on Monday. He wants to be able to include links to previous article and such, and I agreed that we would all learn more by having a thought-out response. Thanks to all of you that took time to submit questions.
Condos in some San Diego areas are being sold $40,000 below 2004 prices! this is amazing Check out the news links today at realestatedecline.com
Just reading an article and they said a good reason to buy now was because rates were low. That is garbage! I would much rather pay a higher rate and a lower price any day of the week. At some point you will most likely be able to refinance to a lower rate. To me, a lower rate and very high price is disaster.
Hopefully rising rates help clean up this mess in the housing market.
I have written this before but here it is again. I have owned my home since 1993 and I have gotten hundreds, maybe even thousands, of offers to lower my interest rate. In the same time frame I have not gotten even one offer from the bank to lower my loan amount.
The whole focus on the payment thing belongs on used car lots, not in the housing market. Since that is what most Loan Officers will be doing in a couple of years, maybe it is good practice for them.
After the Jimmy Carter inflation disaster Paul Volker jerked the RE chain in Oct.1979. My interest rate was 6 1/8% at that time. Remember that the Prime went up to over 15% in a year or so and new loans even higher plus points.. When I sold my home I wrapped the existing with a 12% and carried back. Prior to Wellencamp. I got many calls from my lender (Home S&L)wanting me to payoff for a discount. I calculated my yield and told them what I wanted, and by the way, I wanted more discount because of the tax situation. Tax due because of reduction of debt. Guy at Home said I was too sharp. I asked him how many Sheeple took his offers. He said quite a few. Told him to call me back if he had a better offer. It helped that I didn’t need the money.Never got another call. Wish we could wrap existing low interest loans again. Congress closed that one to pay off Fannie and Freddie and the other banks and S&Ls.
Couldn’t agree more. I got a heck of a deal on a house backin the 80’s when interest was at 18% on a bank account.
surfroggy-
This is the second time this week that I’ve heard of prices being lopped back to 2004 levels in one area or another of the country.
Amazing! One year of RE inflation wiped out so quickly. Very heart warming news.
Ever seen a stock give back 6 months of gains in 3 trading days? Things always seem to go down a lot faster than they go up. Funny how that works, isn’t it? Timing is everything.
txchick
Have not seen you post much lattely. Saw you on SoCal’s Forums. Just for fun I checked the Queen Creek market today and there are 2,200 houses for sale. When I limited the price to 400K there were still 2,000. The house that was listed on my companies classified ad site for 324K is now listed with a realator for 310K. Are you still wanting to move to Phoenix? Take your pick of houses for rent.
Let me know when the weather is condusive to a survivable climate.
Give me timming over brains any day…..Good timming or just plain flat luck can make you look awfully smart…
Yeah. I love it. Here is the actual link pulled from http://www.realestatedecline.com: http://www.voiceofsandiego.org/site/apps/nl/content2.asp?c=euLTJbMUKvH&b=486837&ct=2039913
“Japan’s audacious five-year experiment of force-feeding cash into an ailing economy began to wind down Thursday, chased into history by central bankers convinced that Japanese industry and consumers have risen from their sickbed and no longer need easy credit.”
Too bad the US bubble unraveling is likely to send JA into intensive care…
Does look like its unraveling . Im loosing all hope of a soft landing .
Looks like Phoenix is going through a 30,000 (and 14,000+ empty) soft landings? What about Las Wages. Are they going the way of Phoenix yet? At least people can go to the casinos, get cooled off and drown their sorrows for free. Might not make it back to the overpriced $hitbox though
When are the Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac accounting scandal people going up for trial and a public lynching? At least that is what happened to many of the corporate liars (Enron, Worldcom, Adelphia, etc). Now, that would be entertainment.