An International Symbol For What Went Wrong
The Marin Independent Journal reports from California. “The number of Marin foreclosures in the first quarter of this year spiked 28.1 percent compared with the same period last year, by far the biggest increase in the Bay Area. The number of additional homeowners who fell behind on their mortgage also edged up in Marin, the only county in the region to see such an increase. The figures, released by San Diego-based DataQuick, came as a surprise to some observers in Marin, where the rate of foreclosures still remains one of the lowest in California despite the recent increases.”
“‘Who knows what’s going on out there?’ said George DeSalvo, a broker who specializes in bank-owned properties. ‘I’ve never seen anything like this in my entire life…We’re starting to see more foreclosures in cites like Tiburon, Mill Valley, Corte Madera, where we almost never saw foreclosures.’”
“Many properties have only recently been placed on the market months after the lender foreclosed, said Robert Bradley, president of Bradley Real Estate in San Rafael and a specialist in bank-owned properties. ‘What you’re going to see in the next couple of months is a ton of foreclosures coming out and being put on the market,’ Bradley said.”
The Press Democrat. “Sonoma County has entered the fifth year of the nation’s foreclosure debacle, and each week about 40 borrowers here continue to lose their homes. Lenders foreclosed on 519 county homes in the year’s first quarter, according to San Diego-based DataQuick. That represented an increase of 17 percent from the previous quarter and 5 percent from a year ago.”
“With so many homeowners still at risk of losing their homes, ‘it’s going to be a two- to five-year process to bleed all these properties into the market,’ said John Duran, president of the North Bay Association of Realtor’s Santa Rosa Chapter.”
The Willits News. “The number of foreclosures in Mendocino County is setting new pace in 2011 with an average of 34 per month. This is the largest number of foreclosure sales in a quarter since the recession began. The inventory of bank owned property sitting empty is up to an estimated 260 county properties. This, even as the timeframes between issuing a notice of default and final sales lengthens to 263 days, according to ForeclosureRadar.”
“The pace of sales shows little sign of reaching an end as a substantial inventory of past issued notices of default remains even while new issuances have averaged 59 properties a month so far in 2011. This compares to an average of 51 notices of default in 2010. County properties in default had loans which originated from 2004 through 2008 with most originating in 2006 and 2007.”
“Within California the worst hit area is Madera County with one in 123 homes involved in foreclosure. Los Angeles leads the state with 12,172 properties in foreclosure.”
The Merced Sun Star. “Foreclosures in Stanislaus, Merced and San Joaquin counties dropped to levels not seen since 2007, according to just-released statistics from DataQuick, a real estate data provider. The region’s foreclosure rate has fallen to about half what it was during the 2008 peak of the mortgage mess.”
“That doesn’t mean times are good. Just better. Since the foreclosure crisis began four years ago, about 66,500 Northern San Joaquin Valley homes’ mortgages have defaulted and lenders have taken them back. In Merced County, lenders repossessed 607 homes, which was 5.2 percent more than during the same months last year. Since mid-2006, 12,680 Merced homes have been foreclosed. That’s about 18 percent of the homes and condos in the county.”
The Bakersfield Californian. “The personal income of Kern County residents is just 70 percent of the state’s average income and is declining, according to new federal data, The decline in personal income late in the decade coincides almost perfectly with the collapse of the residential real estate market and the banking crisis that followed. That probably accounts for some of the drop, said Louis Medina, homeless project manager for United Way of Kern County.”
“‘Certainly the people who were using their home equity as banks weren’t able to do that anymore,’ he said.”
“McAllister Ranch has a buyer. The unfinished 6,000-home golf course community in far southwest Bakersfield has been stuck in bankruptcy limbo since September 2008. But an investment affiliate of the original master developer, Irvine-based SunCal Cos., earlier this month won a competitive auction in bankruptcy court.”
“McAllister Ranch became an international symbol for what went wrong at Lehman Brothers, the now-bankrupt New York investment bank, after a $235 million loan from Lehman Commercial Paper Inc. defaulted in spring 2008. That summer, Fortune magazine ran a feature highlighting the unfinished project and its Greg Norman-designed golf course going to weeds. Other media outlets, including the BBC, latched onto the Bakersfield site, where billboards boasting the upscale community long loomed over a barren, dusty patch surrounded by nodding oil rigs.”
“The affiliate, PVCO Land Holdings LLC, paid $71 million in all for three projects: McAllister Ranch and two developments in Riverside County. In all, Lehman loaned more than $300 million to McAllister Ranch and the two Riverside projects.”
The Los Angeles Times. “Growth has altered the skyline of downtown Long Beach over the last decade. New high-rise condo towers dot Ocean Boulevard. Older buildings have been converted into lofts, and a new shopping center and entertainment complex rose on the site of the long-shuttered Pike amusement park. But when the U.S. Census Bureau released population data earlier this year, some in Long Beach were shocked to learn that between 2000 and 2010, the state’s seventh-largest city added only 735 residents — a growth rate of 0.2% and far below the national average of 9.7%.”
“Long Beach is one of several large cities in Southern California to see growth plateau — or in some cases decline — in the last decade. Long Beach Councilman Robert Garcia said his city’s numbers merely reflected the trend of Californians moving farther inland, away from coastal cities, and he advised against any assessment of Long Beach’s future based on the count. ‘If I was walking through downtown and I saw decay, empty buildings, half-built condos, parks that were unfinished, then I’d be worried,’ he said. ‘But the reality is that crime is at a 30-year low, development is happening, we’re still building workforce housing, and I think we’ve got a bright future.’”
LA Downtown News. “MPG Office Trust, the commercial real estate giant that once dominated the Downtown office building scene, is staring at a mountain of debt that it can’t afford to pay and is at risk of defaulting on several of its most prominent buildings. The situation has some wondering if the company that played a key role in shaping the Downtown Los Angeles skyline is built for the future.”
“‘It’s the end of the era for [MPG],’ said Steve Marcussen, executive director of commercial real estate firm Cushman and Wakefield, who believes that lenders on MPG’s core properties will have little incentive to renegotiate their loans to keep MPG in its assets.”
The Orange County Register. “We at this blog have decided to start tracking Orange County’s most exclusive listings. Nah, just homes formally listed for $20 million or more. What did we learn in April’s review of Redfin‘s search of brokers’ most-pricey MLS listings? Still, 10 homes in this club. One significant change this month: The Corona del Mar estate at 169 Shorecliff has had its price cut by $5.445 million in $22.5 million. So it’s now tied for 9th priciest.”
“3 of top 5 are in Laguna Beach. That means that 5 of the 10 now show price reductions, price cuts that total $38 million!”
The San Gabriel Valley Tribune. “Distressed properties accounted for more than half of the homes sold in Los Angeles County in March, down from 55 percent in February but up from 49 percent a year earlier, the California Association of Realtors reported. L.A. County’s 51 percent might seem high, but other regions posted percentages that were far higher. The Inland Empire - which many consider to be ground zero for the housing meltdown - ranked among the worst. In San Bernardino County, 71 percent of the region’s March sales were distressed properties. That was down from 76 percent the previous month and 75 percent in March 2010, CAR reported.”
“Riverside County’s rate of 67 percent for March was down from February’s 71 percent and the year-ago rate of 73 percent. ‘Consistent with the state as a whole, nearly all the counties for which we have data also experienced an improvement in distressed sales,’ CAR President Beth L. Peerce said in a statement. ‘However, distressed sales in most of the counties were higher than a year ago, as the market continues to work through large numbers of troubled mortgages.’”
“Solano County had the highest percentage of distressed property sales for March (76 percent), while Kern County tied with San Bernardino County at 71 percent.”
The Inland Valley Daily Bulletin. “City officials believe construction of the Colonies development has been beneficial to the city overall, despite years and millions of dollars spent on litigation surrounding the project. A document dated in June 2002 estimated the project would generate about $4.3 million for the city annually by 2011 - about twice the actual tax receipts. However, the estimates were based on a complete build-out of the development, and the economic downturn has had an effect on all city revenues, said acting City Manager Steven Dunn.”
“Mary Wright of Upland believes the Colonies residential and commercial developments have done nothing for the city. ‘It’s overcrowded our schools, especially Pioneer Junior High School,’ Wright said. ‘In Upland it’s all about the tax revenue.’”
“Wright said she had attended all the open houses for the development. ‘Half the houses over there are in foreclosure, and there’s a big battle over the water,’ she said.”
The Desert Sun. “A miserable winter, the soaring Canadian dollar and bargain prices are among the reasons snowbirds have embarked on a home-buying spree that has made the Coachella Valley one of the few places in Southern California where sales are rising. Many Canadians are paying cash. And unlike in the U.S., the housing market in most Canadian provinces has remained strong, enabling buyers to set up a line of credit against current real estate assets to finance property purchases in the valley.”
“That’s especially true in western Canada, where real estate values have soared in a region with an oil-based economy. The Canadian Real Estate Association reported the average house price in February was $792,000 in Vancouver, $588,000 in British Columbia and $454,000 in Toronto.”
“‘I’ve got a lot of friends who are really interested in purchasing a home because our dollar is cookin’ right now,’ said Liz Malinka, a Vancouver resident who bought a home in Palm Springs. ‘We come down here and go, ‘Wow,’ Malinka said of valley home prices.”
‘Gene Wunderlich is the Director of Government Affairs for the Southwest Riverside County Association of Realtors… ‘Looking at our local market this month, our sales of single-family residential homes took a nice bounce in most cities in March. We’re still off last year’s record sales pace for the quarter by anywhere from 11 percent in Temecula to 18 percent in Murrieta and 22 percent in Lake Elsinore.’
‘…2010 had a great first half but a weak second. Why was that? The impact of the federal first-time homebuyer program – which removed some 1.5 million homes from the market nationwide and helped prices stabilize from their free-fall. While the program may well have borrowed from future sales, that impact has worn off now and our demand is returning to a more sustainable pace.’
‘Finally, Notice of Default filings in California rose to their highest level since October 2010…The average Time to Foreclose continues to climb, up 4.1 percent month-over-month to 302 days, a significant 83.4 percent increase year-over-year, and a new record.’
‘The average Time to Foreclose continues to climb, up 4.1 percent month-over-month to 302 days, a significant 83.4 percent increase year-over-year, and a new record.’
Sounds like the foreclosure deluge is 302 days away.
I read somewhere that the average time between Notice of Default and actual forceclosure is up to 587 days. That’s a lot of free rent.
Yeah, but that’s not because the process actually takes that long. It’s just because the bankstas are trying hard for more shadow inventory. Like PB said, sounds like the foreclosure deluge in California is about 300 days away.
“That’s especially true in western Canada, where real estate values have soared in a region with an oil-based economy. The Canadian Real Estate Association reported the average house price in February was $792,000 in Vancouver, $588,000 in British Columbia and $454,000 in Toronto.”
Well, I am sure the average wage (3x wages) is:
$264,000 in Vancouver
$196,000 in British Columbia
$151,333 in Toronto
No bubble. Keep borrowing on your present houses to buy even more real estate. We can all be Donald Trump…
Agree. This story of Canadians raiding home equity to buy property in California sounds eerily like Californians raiding home equity to buy property in Oregon.
The only thing man learns from history is that man doesn’t learn from history.
And unlike in the U.S., the housing market in most Canadian provinces has remained strong, enabling buyers to set up a line of credit against current real estate assets to finance property purchases in the valley.
Yup, this will end well.
And, as oxide mentions above, the raiding of CA home equity to buy property in OR sounds a lot like what happened here in AZ. We have quite a few CA HELOC-financed purchases at bubble prices that can’t be sold now. I live right next door to one, in fact.
Actually we can’t all be Donald Trump. He gets to leverage his corrupt political pals to use eminent domain to force the peasants off land he’s set his beady, soulless eyes on. You and me, not so much.
Doesn’t Texas have an oil-based economy? How come real estate prices aren’t rising there?
I’m from Vancouver (something I’m normally proud to say but with the Blackhawks comeback I’m not so sure anymore). If that area has an oil-based economy, it’s news to me. The oil business is big in northern Alberta. Natural gas is big in areas. However, the lower mainland is not that way at all.
These high prices are the result of wild borrowing (50 year mortgages) and speculation. Plenty of money has poured in over the years from Hong Kong but I don’t know how much of the Chinese spending has been with real money. I think much of it has been borrowed.
Young people in Vancouver and the surrounding areas have no chance to buy homes. If you think the housing bubble was bad for buyers in the U.S. you should see prices in Vancouver. Simple homes can be in the millions.
Schweet! … articles and commentary specific to the articles.
Thank you BJ. It this a daily thing now like the old days?
I kinda missed doing it, and my schedule is a bit easier now. If you guys read and comment on these posts, I’ll keep doing them.
definitely nice to see again. this was how I found my way to your blog 5 years ago or so–I had just visited a friend in Phoenix and found out he had a just paid 569 K for a 4 bed 3 bath home in a really average part of scottsdale. And how he was likely to buy a new Toll bros home for a million bucks. When I expressed incredulity at the prices, he told me that “that’s how it is in Phoenix”.
Anyhoo, I when I got back to chicago (where I had already felt that the prices here were unsustainable) I typed in housing bubble phoenix and was led to your blog and it’s been roses ever since. Hope this brings even more people to this blog (as it did me). Thanks again.
(BTW, he did buy the toll bros home. Still no sale on the old home (renting it out at present), and the comps in his neighborhood are about 45-50% of what he paid on the million dollar home. Luckily for him he’s nice and wealthy with real stable mid 6 figure job)
I’m glad they’re back too, Ben.
Very happy they are back Ben, thanks; I missed them!
If you blog, we will read and comment! I’m so happy you’re writing again.
I have to admit, it’s a puzzlement.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ubsd-tWYmZw
Since we’re waxing nostalgic, I just can’t resist posting the most unintentionally honest realtor ad ever: the infamous “The Debate,” a.k.a. “Suzanne Researched This.” A vile sucubus of a wife hectors her spineless husband into making a soon-to-be-disastrous purchase of a new house at the peak of the market - based on the “research” of a realtor who is anything but objective. Of course we all know how this would’ve ended - with our FB couple deep under water, bitter, trading mutual recriminations, possibly divorced or foreclosed on, while Suzanne finds her natual calling as a streetwalker.
Sammy!!!… you just best yourself again!!!!
while Suzanne finds her natual calling as a streetwalker.
methink$ you under-e$timate the capabilitie$ of “$ome” woeman$
Who
re modified with the “L” as in Love = Whole“‘Who knows what’s going on out there?’ said George DeSalvo, a broker who specializes in bank-owned properties. ‘I’ve never seen anything like this in my entire life…We’re starting to see more foreclosures in cites like Tiburon, Mill Valley, Corte Madera, where we almost never saw foreclosures.’”
Got Alt-A resets?
‘I’ve never seen anything like this in my entire life…We’re starting to see more foreclosures in cites like Tiburon, Mill Valley, Corte Madera, where we almost never saw foreclosures.’”
2007 Blast from the past:
“It’s God’s country, what can I say…… When is the 30 percent decline in Marin County’s market going to happen? Not in my lifetime.” Leslie Appleton-Young, chief economist for the California Association of Realtors,
(Is she dead?)
Like all NAR spokespeople, she was paid to dissemble and she had a real talent for it. Her soul must’ve died within her long before she uttered her first lie as NAR shill-in-chief.
God’s country! Whatserface! HAhahahahha. I wonder if that little chubbette is still wearing those ivory-colored pantyhose to work, or if she’s gone back to baking apples like she should be.
“The Inland Empire - which many consider to be ground zero for the housing meltdown - ranked among the worst.”
Serves ‘em right for knocking down all the vineyards and orange groves. I guess I’m lucky I saw it in the old days, before the LA smog reached that far.
+1. A more soulless “community” I’ve never seen.
I saw those Canadian Snow Birds this past week in Palm Springs,prices have held up well in the Desert.I live in Sun City Indio,and prices have dropped,about 20 % from 2005…These are walled and gated subdivisions,that have had the 20% drop.Residential n-hoods, have fallen even further about 40%…The Canadian Money is a big deal to the Desert areas,and this has helped keep prices up… with the
new knife catchers
With the dollar continuing its inexorable decline (thank you, Ben Bernanke) a lot more Canadians are going to be flocking down to snap up “cheap” southwest real estate.
And they will get burned with all the rest of the morons. The dollar going down will just make it worse for them, nothing like losing 1/2 the value of the RE plus 1/2 the value of the currency. Now that really hurts!
I recently purchased a town home 2/2 with 2 car garage on fee land in Rancho Mirage for less than it sold for in 1985.
I think the desert area has dropped at least 50-75%
Walled-in subdivisions.
Yeah, l heard prisons have kept their value pretty well.
Boots on the ground in Bakersfield… The peak in the market was August 2005 here. The bottom has only been found in the last 18 months because new construction is nearly non-existent and the REO holders are not releasing all their holdings on to the local MLS. The census data (which corresponds to April 2010) indicates about an 8.5% vacancy rate on all housing units. I would read that vacancy rate as an oversupply number. Making McAllister Ranch work the way it seems to be planned is going to take a lot of additional upper-middle income employment that does not currently exist.
is going to take a lot of additional upper-middle income employment that does not currently exist.
Jobs!, Jobs!, Jobs!…Bakersfried is anxiously awaiting the “TruePathtoProsperity™” train stop.
“ReadMyLipsrepubicanRedux”: Jobs!, Jobs!, Jobs!
Waiting, waiting, …the Kern Co. “TrueAnger™” folks are anxiously awaiting…for the “TruePurity™” + “TrueEvangelical™” Jobs!, Jobs!, Jobs! Revival employment tent! (-those Tehachapi $olar-wind $tupid-Gubmint energy idea job$)
First of all, I would like to ask whatever happened to LAInvestorGirl? Did she die of poorness? Was she swallowed up by the great sucking sound currently manifesting itself as the housing crash? Did she default?
Secondly, I would like to apologize. I spent some time today posting on a CNN article instead of posting on the HBB. It was a thing about how democrats and republicans are not addressing the issues with the economy. For some reason, however, the author didn’t mention anything about offshoring. I’m like HELLLOOOOO! There were tons of other comments about offshoring though.
It seems that people are waking up to this. Better yet, they all think that they wouldn’t have lost their houses if it weren’t for TARP. I thought that was a nice turn of opinion.
“The personal income of Kern County residents is just 70 percent of the state’s average income and is declining,…”
BWAHAHAHicHAHAHicHAHAHAHAHicHAHAHic* (DennisN™)
The number of additional homeowners who fell behind on their mortgage also edged up in Marin, the only county in the region to see such an increase.
heheeeheeeheehaahaaahaaheeehaahaaa… (Hwy50™)
Bakersfried,…NoSinInMarin
Ho ho, hah hah, hehehehehehe, BwaHaHaAhHAHAHAHAHAHA!!! (Cantankerous Intellectual Bomb-thrower™)
Dumb question of the day:
Does it feel to anyone else like little progress has been made regarding the resolution of the housing bubble since we started reading and posting here back in 2005 or so, or is it just that the snails pace at which resolution occurs naturally leads to a feeling of unmitigated tension?
My personal opinion is we’ve made it to almost the halfway point. So that’s progress to me. But yeah…amazing how much the process can be slowed if the right people desire it.
Agree with Carl. We’re about half-way there.
Bakersfield area is highly dependent in oil drilling companies for full employment.
Bakersfield has high sulphur crude (not sweet crude). I ran a motel near Bakersfield and sold out in during the last oil crash .
Crude around 90-100 will keep oil blue collar jobs and related peripheral spending alive. But not too high salary .
BKSF real estate prices are going to be in a permanent plateau as credit boom which boomed and crashed BKF and Central California (Fresno etc)is folk lore now.
Bernake is bailing out banks on old bad loans but no body is giving “No doc Liar loans” any more
Inland Empire, Norco. In my street (builted beween 2004-6) 7 out of 10 homes are foreclosed or short-saled, most of the buyers used government backed mortgage(90-95%); FHA, VA, etc (3.5% down or less). On top of it lot of buyers used “First time home buyers program”… I see some of new buyers are already having problems, lawn is dead and brown with weeds, renting out rooms, sign of problems…Government trying to stop free fall by lowering interest rate, home buying incentive is causing more problems…
I live on same street.
I hope you are renting, but if you’re not, best of luck to you.
It sucks that some people who were trying to be responsible and put 20% down have been so negatively affected by the no/low-down crowd.
Thanks for your insights!