An Industry That’s Starting To Get Spooked By Luxury
The Portland Tribune reports from Oregon. “Martha McLennan, the executive director of Northwest Housing Alternatives, a nonprofit which builds and administers affordable housing in Oregon, said that she has also seen cases in Portland and Gresham in which a buyer purchases an apartment complex, removes its current tenants, renovates the building and returns it to the rental market at a significantly increased rate. Another problem, McLennan said, is that many of the apartments that have been recently built are geared toward a certain class of buyers. ‘We’ve seen more and more housing coming on the marketplace, but it’s coming in at the highest level,’ she said.”
“When those apartments are snapped up, property managers elsewhere take note, and increase the rate in their own facilities to similar levels, she said. ‘That is resulting in the triple-digit rent increases that people are getting,’ McLennan said.”
The Seattle Times in Washington. “In King County, the average one-bedroom apartment built since 2010 rents for $1,787, according to apartment-market research firm Dupre+Scott. For one-bedrooms in properties built between 1900 and 1944, the average is $1,298. That’s partly because new buildings have more amenities and modern design, said Mike Scott. With their old brick apartment building near Lake Union scheduled for demolition, longtime neighbors Cortney Clayton and Meaghan Howell scrambled to find new homes in Seattle’s hot housing market. They ended up in more expensive places, miles apart, after somewhat stressful searches.”
“Her hunt ‘came down to the wire,’ Howell said. And then she had to make a snap decision. ‘If you don’t want it,’ her new landlord told her in a matter-of-fact way, ‘I have eight people who do.’ The 1927 building was near the epicenter of Seattle’s Amazon-fueled boom. Its 22 units gave way to the wrecking ball and plans by a California developer for a seven-story, full-block design with 282 apartments and 259 parking stalls. Sold 15 years ago for $1.8 million, the property fetched $16.7 million this past summer. ‘It’s really the value of the dirt versus the value of history. And often the dirt has so many zeros after it,’ said Kji Kelly, executive director of Historic Seattle, a preservation group that’s been calling attention to increasing demolitions.”
“In all, 2,104 housing units in Seattle have been demolished since 2012 to make way for new buildings. Permits to demolish an additional 1,647 units are pending or under review.”
WOWT in Nebraska. “If you’re looking for a place to live in Omaha, you’re in luck. Rental properties are booming in the metro. They’re propping up throughout Omaha, mainly in Midtown and Downtown. Molly Skold is VP of Marketing with Midtown Crossing; she says construction on brand new apartments will help with demand in the area. Two years ago, there were 1-bedroom models at Midtown Crossing that cost about $800 a month. Now, Skold says the lowest is $1,000 and they’re 95 percent full. ‘Just in our little pocket of area there are 900 more apartment units and that’s exciting,’ said Skold. ‘Rent is very expensive historically — at all-time highs basically.’”
“UNO’s Research Coordinator David Drozd at The Center for Public Affairs says that competition is also raising rents in Omaha to all-time highs. Drozd says the demand will slow down in the coming years as the demanding population gets older he says developers should be cautious. ‘It’s going to soften at some point so you don’t want to get overbuilt the way that Arizona or Florida did with some of their units,’ said Drozd.”
The Philadelphia Business Journal in Pennsylvania. “A question that continually comes up is how is Philadelphia’s apartment market doing and whether the city can absorb multifamily projects hitting the market or in the pipeline. Axiometrics, a firm that tracks the multifamily and student housing markets, finds the Philadelphia apartment market has been ‘volatile’ during the last three months. Apartment landlords in new and not-so new apartments have started to compete for renters by enticing them with a range of offers.”
“A cursory review of a dozen properties show some of the most common concessions include move-in specials, reduced rates on select units, special offers on others and at least one-month free. The need to lure renters in with concessions, no matter how small, does say something about the market and that it may be softening a tad as more new or converted properties come online.”
“Axiometrics was also concerned about continued job growth in the city, noting 600 new jobs were generated during the last 12 months. As it stands now, 4,380 apartments are under construction or expected to come available during the next 36 months in the city.”
Real Estate World on New York. “In spite of Manhattan’s growing supply of luxury condominiums, there are signs that expensive apartments are starting to lose their appeal with buyers. According to Douglas Elliman’s third quarter report, the price per square foot in Manhattan hit a new record of $1,497. The biggest deal during the period was for ‘Penthouse One’ at luxury condo building, The Charles, which sold for $38 million. While the transaction is typical real estate headline fodder, it may stand as the high point for an industry that’s starting to get spooked by ultra-luxury condos that are staying vacant.”
“‘I think in general it’s hard to be across-the-board bullish about new condo development in New York. In fact, I think the opposite is much closer to the truth,’ said Lauren Hochfelder Silverman, a managing director at Morgan Stanley Real Estate Investing. According to research from Douglas Elliman, newly constructed apartments that were sold during the third quarter spent 125 days on the market, up from 88 days during the same period a year before.”
“As Silverman’s firm sours on high-end condos, at least one capital source remains optimistic about condo development. According to John Galiano, a senior managing director at Tishman Speyer, Chinese investors remain bullish on condos. ‘A lot of money that been coming out of China, just from a cultural perspective, their view is a lot more shorter-term than your typical investor. They’re doing more strategic acquisition unless it’s condo development, because condo development will turn into capital quickly. I think that’s one of the interesting dynamics when you’re thinking about where capital’s coming from for deals,’ he said. Some of the newest condo projects in town are either being developed or targeted towards the Chinese.”
Community Impact Newspaper on Texas. “Residential developers are continuing to eye the Tomball and Magnolia area for a number of new master-planned communities and subdivision expansions amid a nationwide slump in the price of crude oil. Meanwhile, the steepest decline of home sales for the year in the Greater Houston area took place during the month of October, according to a Houston Association of Realtors report from Nov. 11. Single-family home sales fell 10.2 percent compared to October 2014.”
“While the oil industry remains uncertain, new homes are continuing to be built despite an overall decrease in home buying in the area, according to HAR statistics. This trend can be seen in both Tomball and Magnolia as buyers are waiting to see how new residential development affects the real estate market, said Pat Navarette, owner and broker at Tomball-based real estate company Texas Sage Properties.”
“‘All of a sudden we’ve had an influx of sellers that were going to sell, but now they want to hold onto property and lease it and see if the market turns [around] next year,’ Navarette said. ‘We’re leasing [properties] as quickly as we can get them.’”
“Navarette said an increase in inventory early next year could help the area become more of a buyer’s market. However, she said she does not anticipate the market to return to conditions similar to 2008 before the nationwide housing market collapse. ‘It’s going to take a year or more [for the market to stabilize], and I don’t know that it will ever be the way it was before,’ Navarette said. ‘But it’s actually kind of healthy that it’s swaying back and forth like this.’”
‘We’ve seen more and more housing coming on the marketplace, but it’s coming in at the highest level,’
- Growing stockpile of high-end luxury housing…
- Shrinking pool of wealthy buyers…
“Houston, we have a problem. “
‘We’ve seen more and more housing coming on the marketplace, but it’s coming in at the highest level,’
And presto! Equity is created; Equity is created JUST LIKE MAGIC due to the higher prices.
Higher prices for rents translate to higher prices for the houses that generate the rents which translates to higher prices for all houses - the comps - whether they are rented out or not, and these higher prices produce EQUITY!
In our world of PFM (Pure Fking Magic) rising prices create equity and equity is wealth, hence rising prices create wealth.
Thus … it is all good.
Higher prices+ new building = lotsa new equity.
Presto!
Not only that, but a shrinking pool of wealthy renters. I’m not sure how our idiot leaders expect to conjure a healthy consumer economy out of circumstances where more and more money must go towards shelter and healthcare. More war might be the approach.
And a shrinking capacity to shack up. I’m sure that the only reason these LL’s are getting away with offering only high-rent luxury amenities is that renters are stuffing one income into each bedroom. That’s enough to buy a couple of years of rent increases, but since this started a couple years ago, that time has run out.
I’ve mentioned how often the word “frenzy” has been associated with the multi-family blowout. These reports are more of the same; low income housing renovated into more expensive doors. New stuff is all luxury. The tax code and GSE lending is driving it. I wonder if Mel Watts reads these stories of rents doubling? What will break it down is a recession.
“Houston, we have a problem. “
SugarLand(Houston), TX Housing Craters; Prices Plunge 7% YoY
http://www.movoto.com/sugar-land-tx/market-trends/
Housing, health care and higher ed costs are going through the roof, and these three items comprise the lion’s share of expenditures for many American households.
Yet headline inflation (which excludes the “volatile food and energy sectors”) barely registers as positive.
‘Tis a puzzlement!
Could this phenomenon of rising prices with no reported inflation to match be an example of the “dry cleaner” effect Ben often mentions?
“‘Tis a puzzlement!”
As for higher houses prices and higher education costs the PRICES are not the determining factors that creates the expenses, instead it’s the monthly payments of the loans that are taken out that determines the expenses.
The house’s loan expense is experienced right away but the education’s loan expense can be deferred (and if it can be deferred then, hey, it doesn’t seem to be real).
“According to John Galiano, a senior managing director at Tishman Speyer, Chinese investors remain bullish on condos.”
I remain bearish on Chinese investor demand, in the wake of their home-grown stock-market, housing and commodities crashes. And their ability to borrow and spend their way out of difficulty is loosing its heft in the face of a massive and growing capacity glut.
In a quasi-communist state you can keep the smoke and mirrors up for a much longer time. Eventually chickens will come home to roost.
True or false:
If the GSEs had been wound down as scheduled after Uncle Sam bailed them out, the Echo Bubble would never have occurred.
But if the echo bubble never occurred then we wouldn’t have had the “economic recovery” because the echo bubble wouldn’t have been there to magically generate wealth.
I have a hunch that a lot of far more productive economic recovery paths were blocked by housing bubble reflation.
Not sure I can agree with that; in theory ’tis true, but just look at all of the industries that benefit in the short term from a housing bubble - everything from appliance manufacturers to siding contractors, who go out and buy new pickemup trucks.
I love Zillow; Zillow say’s I’m rich because strangers bid up the price of houses that are comparable to my house, and when the prices of the comparables are bid up then the amount of equity I possess increases.
If there was no echo bubble then my equity would not increase and hence Zillow wouldn’t tell me that I am rich.
So relax, and love the bubble.
You owe it to yourself to take out a HELOC so you can cash out your home equity wealth gains.
Yes, I should do that so that after I retire I will get to enjoy the benefits of paying off a mortgage.
Interestingly:
Zestimate
$357,537
-$5,792 Last 30 days
bush bad tries to reign in gse’s and got killed
Vero Beach, FL Housing Craters; Prices Plummet 9% YoY
http://www.movoto.com/vero-beach-fl/market-trends/
At the end of the bull market after the first and second tier stocks have risen and have premium valuations the most profitable phase occurs when junk stocks fly. Remember Y2K
In housing condos are the last leg of the real estate market.
When the wind blows even Pigs and Turkeys fly. I am not sure if it’s Pigs or Turkeys which fly.
“I am not sure if it’s Pigs or Turkeys which fly.”
It’s pigs. Pigs are the ones that fly.
https://www.google.com/search?q=flying+pigs&biw=1360&bih=643&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&sqi=2&ved=0ahUKEwiVodvI57_JAhVBR2MKHQT9BTAQsAQIGw
remember the Philly bus to freedom riders of 2005 ?
get on da bus -get approved
Napa, CA Housing Craters; Prices Plummet 11% YoY
http://www.movoto.com/napa-ca/market-trends/
congrats, you got list and per sq ft negative
It is the falling transaction price that is important here. $/sq ft will fall as demand plummets and transaction prices continue to fall.
What additional items were include in a sale where the transaction price fell YoY and the $/sq.ft. rose?
MSM claiming housing recovery is solid
where are any markets still possitive?
inventory declined slightly here s of DC soviet as hitlery approaches
any thoughts?
Remember…… A ‘housing recovery’ is falling prices to dramatically lower and more affordable levels, by definition.
Irving, TX Housing Craters; Prices Plunge 12% YoY
http://www.movoto.com/irving-tx/market-trends/
Housing losses…building, building and building.
‘The Leeds School of Business in Boulder predicted Wednesday that the high demand for residential and commercial property in and around Denver will continue for another year, though at an increasingly slower pace. Real estate sales volumes in Denver are expected to rise again in 2016 because of continued population growth and new construction that can’t keep up with demand, said Brian Lewandowski, a Leeds School of Business research associate.’
‘Economic metrics like in-migration, population growth, and a growing Front Range job market make a real estate bust in the Denver area unlikely in 2016, Lewandowski said. The forecast for Denver was welcome news in Grand Junction, where local brokers say the pitch to Front Range retirees is, “Sell at peak market in Denver and buy now in Grand Junction, where quality inventory is high and prices are low — then bank the difference.”
‘A worthy proposal, Lewandowski said, but he believed it unlikely that Denver real estate has much of an impact on the price of homes in Grand Junction. “It’s hard to say, because the Grand Junction market hasn’t necessarily been impacted on the upswing, so why would we expect it to be impacted on the downside?” he asked.’
“Colorado Real Estate: How Long Will the Boom Last?” is one of several topics to be discussed at the Denver forum, Lewandowski said.’
‘Employment and population growth are fueling real estate prices in Denver, but not in Grand Junction, Lewandowski said. “Grand Junction is one of those places that is still struggling to climb out of the recession,” he said, “Meanwhile in Denver, Boulder, Fort Collins, Greeley — they’ve all passed their pre-recession peaks for employment, home prices, personal wage growth and several other metrics.”
“Last year, transaction growth was flat for the same period,” Robert Bray said. “(The) median price for October-only sales was $195,000.”
‘Another sign of the improving local real estate market was the number of single-family housing permits issued in October — up more than 50 percent compared to the same month last year.’
In a side-bar it says this:
‘Homes for sale in the Red Rocks Valley subdivision off of South Camp Road are in the $300,000 range.’
From the comments:
‘By James
It was shocking to see the “actual value” of my property on Grand Valley Drive, as shown on the Mesa County Assessor’s website.’
‘By RAGENA
Go try and sell it James and see if you even come close…..’
If you look at the photo of those $300k houses, you’ll see the slightly snug foot-print that is common everywhere.
I got this:
‘Just Reduced!’
‘5787 Calpine Drive, Malibu’
‘A beautiful 3 bedroom home designed by Blair Ballard, situated on 1.09 lush acres with ocean view in prestigious Malibu Park, surrounded by magical gardens with roses, fruit trees and tropical landscaping, a salt water Spa to relax in under the stars while listening to the surf, make this home exceptional. The architectural style invites natural light throughout and there is a splendid view from every room. Wrap around decks on 2 levels reflect the amazing California sunsets. Cozy Fireplace in living room. European kitchen with granite counters.Downstairs Master bedroom and a guest/ junior suite, both with ensuite marble bathrooms and private balcony. A flagstone garden patio is ideal for entertaining and BBQs. Oversized 2 car garage and ample private guest parking. Separate laundry room plus storage area, and the entire lower level available for storage. Room for pool, guest house, vineyard. Underground utilities. Close to schools, shops, Zuma Beach, hiking trails.’
‘Now Offered at $2,270,000′
http://www.zillow.com/homedetails/5787-Calpine-Dr-Malibu-CA-90265/20556326_zpid/
For Sale
$2,270,000
Price cut: -$25,000 (11/18)
Zestimate®: $2,229,127
Est. Mortgage
$8,376/mo
Last sold: Apr 2004 for $1,125,000
Price History
Date Event Price $/sqft Source
11/18/15 Price change $2,270,000-1.1% $1,120 Westside Estat…
08/26/15 Listed for sale $2,295,000+0.7% $1,133 Westside Estat…
04/07/15 Listing removed $2,280,000 $1,125 Westside Estat…
03/02/15 Listed for sale $2,280,000-0.7% $1,125 Westside Estat…
09/27/14 Listing removed $2,295,000 $1,133 Westside Estat…
04/02/14 Listed for sale $2,295,000+14.8% $1,133 Westside Estat…
04/10/13 Listing removed $1,999,900 $987 Sotheby’s Inte…
02/23/13 Listed for sale $1,999,900+0.8% $987 Sotheby’s Inte…
03/03/12 Listing removed $1,985,000 $980 Sotheby’s Inte…
12/02/11 Price change $1,985,000-6.4% $980 Sotheby’s Inte…
09/09/11 Listed for sale $2,120,000 $1,046 Sotheby’s Inte…
07/29/11 Listing removed $x,xxx/mo – –
07/11/11 Listing removed $1,990,000 $982 Sotheby’s Inte…
07/11/11 Listed for rent $x,xxx/mo – –
07/03/11 Price change $1,990,000 $982 Sotheby’s Inte…
05/22/11 Listing removed $x,xxx/mo – –
05/21/11 Listed for rent $x,xxx/mo – –
05/02/11 Price change $2,120,000 $1,046 Sotheby’s Inte…
02/05/11 Listing removed $x,xxx/mo – –
02/01/11 Listed for rent $x,xxx/mo – –
12/18/10 Listing removed $x,xxx/mo – –
12/04/10 Listed for rent $x,xxx/mo – –
11/10/10 Price change $2,150,000-1.4% $1,061 Sotheby’s Inte…
05/14/10 Price change $2,180,000+1.4% $1,076 –
11/21/09 Price change $2,150,000-8.5% $1,061 Coldwell Banke…
09/09/09 Price change $2,350,000-4.1% $1,160 Coldwell Banke…
08/10/09 Price change $2,450,000-2.0% $1,209 –
05/11/09 Price change $2,500,000-5.7% $1,234 –
09/18/08 Listed for sale $2,650,000-7.0% $1,308 NRT
05/19/08 Listing removed $2,850,000 $1,407 Homes & Land
05/12/08 Price change $2,850,000-3.4% $1,407 Homes & Land
05/01/08 Price change $2,950,000-1.5% $1,456 Homes & Land
04/26/08 Listed for sale $2,995,000 $1,479 Homes & Land
03/24/08 Listing removed $2,995,000 $1,479 Number1Expert
12/06/07 Listed for sale $2,995,000-4.2% $1,479 Number1Expert
08/06/07 Listing removed $3,125,000 $1,543 –
06/15/07 Listed for sale $3,125,000+178% $1,543 Agent
04/20/04 Sold $1,125,000 $555 Public Record
That’s the craziest price history I’ve seen.
A flip from 2004 that has still not sold?
The alligator of carrying costs must be eating the flippers alive.
Wonder how much of this flip is on 25% credit cards…?
$15,000 a year in property tax.
Looks like $2 million is their break even point. Of course that moves up about $25K per year
Assuming they are renting it out…
That’s a beautiful sunset photo. But let’s cut to the chase. If that house is going to get sold, the number 8 needs to appear more.
Hmmm…. $100k in materials and labor. An acre of dirt is worth what…. $1000? $2000 at best?
You don’t get to $2.5 million without fraud. Full tilt fraud.
“Hmmm…. $100k in materials and labor. An acre of dirt is worth what…. $1000? $2000 at best?”
It’s not an acre of dirt in the middle of OK. You have to give them at least
8k for that one, at least until half of it slides down the hill.