The Next Natural Step In The Evolution Of The Downturn
The Union Tribune reports from California. “San Diego County home prices fell to a 3 1/2-year low in October, while sales activity rose from September in spite of last month’s wildfires, DataQuick reported Tuesday. The overall median for October stood at $460,000, down $10,000 from September and 6.1 percent lower than October 2006’s $490,000. The latest figure represented an 11.1 percent decline from the peak of $517,500, reached in November 2005.”
“The last time the median was this low was in April 2004. October sales totaled 2,327…still 32.5 percent lower than year-ago levels, and marked the 41st consecutive month of year-over-year declines.”
“There were 1,085 houses resold, down 40.1 percent from a year ago. Condo resales totaled 529, down 14.8 percent from a year ago.”
The Wall Street Journal. “As the glut of unsold home remains stubbornly high and housing demand slides, home builders face a dilemma: to sell, or not to sell?”
“Lennar Corp., for one, has joined the ‘not to sell’ camp at its development in Orange County, Calif. The Miami company plans to finish building 259 homes, the first phase of a 1,100-unit development in Irvine, but it has decided not to sell any of them until the constrained mortgage market and swollen housing inventory improves.”
“‘We are better off holding off on sales at this asset and not discounting as steeply as the market is discounting right now,’ says Emile Haddad, Lennar’s chief investment officer, who oversees the company’s large West Coast projects.”
“Analysts expect more builders to mothball projects in the coming months, as they decide that the losses from selling homes at huge discounts are greater than the costs of carrying properties on their books.”
“But it’s not an easy decision. Builders are facing increasing pressure from lenders to service their debt and also have overhead expenses to support.”
“‘It’s the next natural step in the evolution’ of the housing downturn, says Nishu Sood, a home-builder analyst at Deutsche Bank. ‘This normally happens during a recession when you just don’t have a base of demand. But it’s like that now. In some of these locations, you just can’t give a house away.’”
“Standard Pacific Corp., of Irvine, Calif., has been offering discounts and other incentives of as much as 25% on certain homes.”
“Lennar CEO Stuart Miller recently called some price cuts ‘unrealistic and maybe even ridiculous.’ ‘The market has just deteriorated more and more. We don’t want to go below a certain floor, and that is the floor of reasonableness,’ Mr. Miller told analysts on a conference call in late September.”
“Lennar’s move in Orange County is unusual in that the company is mothballing homes. Builders typically mothball partially developed or undeveloped land because vacant homes require watching. One alternative would be for builders to sell their land instead, but that market is even more dismal than the one for housing.”
“Recent land transactions in California, Phoenix and Southeast Florida, while few in number, have fetched discounts of 70% and 80% on finished lots, according to Zelman & Associates.”
“‘They have all this land that they need to turn over, so they keep building,’ says Paul Puryear, an analyst at Raymond James & Associates. ‘We would recover so much quicker if you could just turn it off, but you can’t turn it off.’”
“Considering there are too many houses already looking for buyers, it might seem surprising that builders are building at all. But…it can take years for a housing development to makes its way through the development pipeline. By the time the builder has spent money putting in roads and sidewalks, the housing market may have turned.”
“‘Many builders are stuck between a rock and hard place,’ says Jonathan Dienhart, director of published research at a housing research firm in Costa Mesa, Calif. ‘They can’t make money by building, and they can’t make money by not building. They have to choose the lesser of two evils.’”
“Lennar’s Mr. Haddad says the builder had to finish constructing the first phase of its Irvine project, called Central Park West, where the mix of condos and town homes had an average price of $700,000.”
“‘You create a stigma for a community if it’s only half built,’ Mr. Haddad says. The 14 buyers who signed contracts for the 259 homes got their deposits back.”
The Contra Costa Times. “The mortgage morass has engulfed E-Loan, an online loan firm that said Monday it intends to chop more than 400 jobs from its Pleasanton headquarters as part of a wrenching and broad restructuring.”
“Employees were notified they would be dismissed at the end of last week. E-Loan intends to cut 410 of the roughly 925 jobs at its headquarters in the East Bay, said Laurie Azzano, a spokeswoman for Pleasanton-based E-Loan.”
“‘It’s a challenging mortgage climate for all of us right now,’ Azzano said.”
“In the past year, 8,100 East Bay jobs in four key industries tied directly to housing — residential construction, specialty trades construction, real estate and credit intermediation — have vanished.”
“‘E-Loan is not a subprime lender,’ Azzano said. ‘The company has a higher quality borrower. These layoffs are not a result of the subprime in particular but the mortgage problems as a whole.’”
“Industry veterans said the E-Loan job reductions epitomize the misery in the housing and mortgage industries. ‘Every lender I know of has laid off dramatic numbers of people,’ said John Holmgren, president of an East Bay mortgage group.”
“East Bay loan agents routinely find fresh evidence that the problems in the industry haven’t started to decrease. ‘We hear from agents all the time that they go out to call on broker clients and find when they get there the office was closed,’ Holmgren said.”
The Press Democrat. “The postmortem on how the housing bubble burst has exposed the precarious relationship between homebuyers and the people who helped them get a mortgage.”
“Angry disputes are erupting between struggling homeowners, who claim they didn’t understand the terms of their loan or the risk they were taking, and lenders and loan brokers, who say they fully informed all their clients and point with pride to the many homeowners they helped get a loan.”
“‘In so many ways, what we’re seeing today was caused by all this crazy borrowing and lending,’ said economist Christopher Thornberg, who has repeatedly warned of a looming real estate crisis. ‘I can’t emphasize this enough. This was imminently predictable.’”
“Brokers and lenders say the criticism is unfair. They maintain that they provided an important service, plowing through scores of arcane loans to find the best one their client could qualify for. They say they were under pressure from borrowers and from real estate agents who could take their business elsewhere.”
“They say it was the lender’s job to decide if the borrowers were qualified and able to repay the loan.”
“No one takes responsibility for the inflated incomes that many borrowers submitted to justify a mortgage, especially in 2005 and 2006 after three years of soaring home prices. One lender’s review of 100 loans made without proof of income found that nine out of 10 applications overstated the borrower’s income.”
“While some borrowers may have been misled, others were eager to get a loan regardless of the cost or the risk, several real estate and loan brokers said. ‘I know a lot of lenders who suggested to people not to proceed with the loans. Sometimes they’d go somewhere else, to someone who would give them the loan,’ said Bob Accornero, a real estate broker in Santa Rosa.”
“‘Those are the same individuals coming back and saying, ‘We should have listened. Is there anything we can do?’ said Anna Macias De Leon, owner of a First Priority Financial office in Santa Rosa.”
“‘Lenders had a fiduciary duty to do the right thing for their people,’ said Accornero. ‘Lenders needed to get warm and fuzzy with their people and say, ‘Can you really do this?’’ That’s what they didn’t do.’”
“Homebuyers need to make sure they understand the terms of a loan before they sign on the dotted line, Harper said.”
“‘The lenders are trying to make the biggest mortgages they can. It’s up to you to say, ‘Wait a minute. I don’t think that makes sense for me to bite off this much,’ said Harper, whose service has seen a 300 percent increase in demand for housing counseling this year.”
“People don’t ask enough questions, he said. ‘Simply because a lender tells you that you qualify for a certain amount doesn’t mean you can afford it,’ he said.”
The Times Delta. “Dozens of foreclosed homes are flooding the Visalia-area market — many of them suddenly owned by Fannie Mae because owners could no longer make mortgage-loan payments.”
“But just because these homes have been taken back by Fannie Mae and its various lending partners, don’t look for bargain-basement fire sales — even in a down real estate market, local real estate professionals say.”
“‘We had eight offers on [Fannie Mae-] foreclosed homes in August,’ said Sherrie Weece, a licensed agent for the past eight years in Visalia. ‘All were turned away by Fannie Mae and came back to us.’”
“The reason? The offers came in at an average of $60,000 less than the ‘market price’ set by Fannie Mae, not enough for the mammoth privately owned mortgage conglomerate, even in a sluggish market where prices are declining, Weece said.”
“‘We’ve tightened [Fannie Mae's] underwriting and pricing,’ said Daniel Mudd, Fannie Mae’s CEO, during the Friday briefing from Fannie Mae headquarters. That’s the reason why the August sales fell through in Visalia, Weece said.”
“Weece said that her company currently has 45 foreclosed homes in its inventory. ‘Sixty more are on the way,’ Weece said. ‘This is a good thing for prospective buyers.’”
“Nine of the 11 homes in the Visalia sample were located on the edges of the city, with only two homes located in established neighborhoods. An eviction was served on one of the homes in Visalia. A fresh foreclosure noticed was taped on another home, along with dead strips of black straw that used to be fresh sod.”
“‘Some of these homes haven’t been occupied for four or five months,’ Weece said.”
“Visalia City Councilman Greg Collins has warned for years that development far from Visalia’s core areas might have downsides…in the event of an economic downturn.”
“‘But [foreclosures are] a separate issue,’ Collins said. ‘Even a well-funded infill project in the middle of Visalia would have a hard time selling in this market.’”