Is The Sky Falling In California?
The LA Times reports from California. “Southern California home sales tumbled to a 15-year low in August but the median home price continued to rise despite mounting industry woes, data released today show. Sales last month were the worst since 1992, according to DataQuick. In August, 17,755 homes were sold in the six-county region, compared with 27,875 a year ago, for a 36.3% drop.”
“‘Things are slow, but the big question is, ‘Is this a normal post-cycle lull or is the sky falling?’ I don’t think we know yet,’ said John Karevoll, DataQuick’s chief analyst.”
“What seems like a baffling combination of statistics, a plunge in sales but a rise in prices, is really a function of what kinds of homes are selling, experts say. But the story is different in lower-cost areas, especially in outlying communities that attracted first-time home buyers during the recent boom. Not only are sales falling faster, but median prices are declining.”
“Last month, the median price in Riverside County fell 6.1% to $394,523 and sales plummeted 46.4% compared with August 2006. In San Bernardino County, the median price fell 1.6% to $360,000 while sales tumbled 47.2%.”
“Elsewhere in Southern California, San Diego County’s median price fell 4% to $475,000 and sales fell 19.4%. In Ventura County, the median price fell 4.2% to $575,000 while sales fell 31.2%.”
The Press Enterprise. “In Riverside County, 2,834 homes were sold in August at a median prices of $394,523. It marks the first time the median sales price dropped below $400,000 since November 2005.”
“‘It looks like we’re pretty close to a ’floor’ level of purchase activity right now,’ DataQuick president Marshall Prentice said. ‘Market uncertainty has squeezed out most discretionary buying.’”
The Union Tribune. “The price of a home in San Diego County tumbled to a median $475,000 last month, down $20,000 from a year ago and $14,000 from July, as the number of sales continued falling, DataQuick reported Wednesday. There were 19.4 percent fewer sales than there were a year ago.”
The Orange County Register. “It’s official! O.C. home shoppers have failed to meet the year-ago buying pace for the 23rd straight month, eclipsing the previous longest losing streak back in 1989-91. The sales slump decidedly worsened in the year’s middle third: May to August, a typical year’s prime selling season.”
“DataQuick reports that 2,285 residences of all types were sold last month. That’s down 33.9% from a year ago and 48.9% below the average August in DataQuick’s 20-year history of O.C. sales data. August was so slow that it was the slowest August in DataQuick’s records back to ‘88 and the 11th slowest month overall.”
“Foreclosures in Orange County spiked last month to their highest level in nearly a decade. Banks foreclosed on 469 homes in August, the highest since October 1997, reports DataQuick.”
“And lenders sent out 1,476 notices of default last month, the highest in nearly 11 years. Default notices rose 26.5 percent from July and 196.4 percent from a year ago.”
“Who’s more to blame for the rise in foreclosures, overstretched working families who may have been preyed upon by predatory lenders, or speculators who bought homes for investment purposes? Economist Ryan Ratcliff of the UCLA Anderson Forecast analyzed the data and concluded that it’s the former.”
“More from Ratcliff: ‘(T)he lack of wider financial distress in the economy suggests that this spike in foreclosures is fundamentally different than previous cycles, the days when homeowners ate Top Ramen and let the repo man take the car before missing a mortgage payment may be a thing of the past.’”
“‘But this need not imply that today’s homeowners are somehow less conscientious about their finances. It may be that the mortgage payment has become so large that Top Ramen makes little difference, or that the lack of refinance opportunities and the adverse incentive of a huge prepayment penalty if you do refinance simply make foreclosure the least terrible of a set of terrible choices.’”
The Daily News. “The slumping housing market and rising foreclosures will continue to erode California’s economy until late next year or early 2009, but UCLA forecasters still maintain it will not tug the state into recession, according to a report released this morning.”
“‘With housing as weak as it is, the rest of the economy is going to keep its head above water. This is the glass is half full kind of a take,’ said University of California, Los Angeles, senior economist Ryan Ratcliff, author of the California report.”
“Ratcliff said that the forecast takes into account the mortgage sector turmoil that has so far resulted in thousands of job losses and some major players going bankrupt or closing down.”
“He also offered this caveat during an interview. ‘If it gets significantly worse than it’s been then maybe that’s enough to push us into recession without another source of weakness,’ he said.”
“Leslie Appleton-Young, chief economist at the California Association of Realtors, agrees that it will be at least until 2009 before the residential real estate market experiences anything resembling a rebound.”
“She also expects prices to fall by various amounts depending on the severity of the foreclosure situation. ‘I don’t think we’ve bottomed out yet. I think that will happen in 2008,’ she said.”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “The Bay Area should fare much better than the rest of the state, according to a widely watched forecast. ‘We still think we’re just going to get grazed by the bullet,’ UCLA economist Ryan Ratcliff said.”
“Local builders are hunkering down. ‘We’ve cut back, and we’re still in the process of cutting,’ said Kile Morgan, chairman of Ponderosa Homes in Pleasanton.”
“A few years ago, Ponderosa was building 250 to 300 single-family homes a year, with a median price of about $850,000. Now it’s down to fewer than 150 homes and has slashed its workforce to 50 from about 65, Morgan said. Its subcontractors, who do actual construction, have shrunk similarly.”
“‘Everybody’s looking for where the bottom is,’ he said.”
“Wells Fargo & Co. economist Scott Anderson stresses the risks of a statewide economic downturn more than UCLA forecasters do, pointing to how vital construction and other housing-related jobs have been to the state’s growth in recent years.”
“‘The odds of a recession (in California) are closer to 40 percent, given the outsized dependence on housing,’ Anderson said.”
“Both Anderson and UCLA forecasters stress that the biggest risk to California’s economy is that the housing slump will prove worse than they predict. ”
The Mercury News. “So far, the impact has been relatively small, according to the UCLA forecast and one released by the University of the Pacific Business Forecasting Center.”
“‘The consumer continues to spend,’ said Sean M. Snaith, who helped prepare the University of Pacific’s California and Metro report, which foresees a decline in housing prices through 2008 that ‘will not remotely resemble a bursting bubble.’”
“‘No question about it, we’re slowing a little,’ said Stephen Levy of the Center for Continuing Study of the California Economy. But the valley’s economy is ‘carried by the world, so the U.S. recession will hurt us, but will not take away the luster.’”
“‘By and large the soft landing is still the story,’ the UOP’s Snaith said. ‘It’s been a more turbulent landing that we would have liked, and it’s going to be little longer before we take off again.’”
“UCLA’s Anderson Forecast on the California economy also found ‘little evidence that mortgage defaults have led to wider financial distress for consumers.’”
The Central Valley Business Times. “A total of 9,477 properties, with a total loan value of $3.86 billion, were sold at auction in California last month, a 10.4 percent increase over July, according to a Discovery Bay-based foreclosure information service.”
“Speculator-owned properties (non-owner occupied properties) accounted for $1.71 billion of that total and represented 44.3 percent, or 4,199 of the properties sold at foreclosure auction.”
“CEO Sean O’Toole says the subprime market took the first hit as those borrowers had the least to lose when they walked away. ‘Now that nearly half of foreclosures represent non-owner occupied properties, it is clear that speculators are walking away too,’ he says.”
“Almost all (90.3%) of all foreclosure sales in California in August were for homes purchased or refinanced in 2005 and 2006. Of properties sold at auction, 95% went back to the bank, for a total of 9,015 properties with a loan value of $3.7 billion.”
From KGET.com. “FBI agents and other federal authorities were searching the home and offices of real estate agent David Crisp and his family and associates Wednesday morning.”
“On Monday, the California Department of Real Estate issued a formal accusation that said Crisp acquired homes in the area, then dramatically raised the prices of the properties.”
“Several of the homes already are in default. If they go to foreclosure, the mortgage company will sell them, but stand to lose hundreds of thousands of dollars because, experts say, the loans were made for more than the properties are worth.”
The Bakersfield Californian. “The home of Crisp’s mother was searched by FBI agents. And at around 11 a.m. Wednesday, two men were seen being led from the home in handcuffs and into a Bakersfield Police Department vehicle.”
The Press Democrat. “Owning a home means paying down a car loan, giving up dinners out and other scrimping for Reyna and Richard Jackson. The Santa Rosa couple, who bought their first home this summer, spend nearly half of their income on their monthly mortgage payment.”
“‘It is a big chunk,’ Reyna Jackson said. ‘It’s hard, it’s stressful. So far, so good.’”
“‘The thing that drove people to say ‘I’ll pay that’ was the fear of not getting in the game and never being able to buy a house,’ said Randy Blankenbaker, regional manager for Chase Home Mortgage.”
“During the run-up in home prices, houses increasingly were viewed as investments instead of shelter. ‘That was certainly the gamble. They weren’t thinking of it as a place to live, they were thinking of it more as an investment,’ said Darren Seliga, owner of Seliga Financial in Santa Rosa.”
“Many loans were made without requiring buyers to document income or assets. ‘Any loan officer can add and divide to come up with the figure to qualify. There’s no question that everybody may have overstated incomes,’ Blankenbaker said.”
“But the housing boom was not sustainable. High prices pushed out more buyers and made others wary of purchasing homes. The market peaked in 2005, followed by a slump that has seen prices fall the past 13 months. The county’s median home price is $575,000, down 9.3 percent from its August 2005 peak.”
“The Jacksons didn’t want to wait longer to purchase their first house. After a year of looking and watching prices fall, they bought a three-bedroom house in southeast Santa Rosa in July for $395,000 that originally was listed in February for $482,000. The deal went through after the seller’s lender approved the sale for less than what was owed on the mortgage.”
“‘We were nervous about getting into a house because of the mortgage payment. But we had to just do it. Even if the home prices went down more, lenders are getting more strict and it could be harder to get a loan,’ Reyna Jackson said. ‘A year ago, there was no way we could afford a home. It was definitely worth the wait.’”
“The Jacksons’ monthly housing costs jumped from $1,300 in rent for a Windsor house to $3,092 for their mortgage, taxes and insurance. To make ends meet means fewer new clothes, more frugal grocery purchases and other cutbacks.”
“‘I combine our errands so I don’t waste gas,’ she said. ‘We definitely live a different life.’”