Renting The Home They Had Bought In California
The Times Press Recorder reports from California. “For Don and Rebecca Spendlove, just keeping a roof over their heads has taxed their mental, emotional and physical as well as financial capabilities. The Nipomo couple have found themselves in the same situation as millions of other Americans: Their homes are worth less than they owe, their mortgage terms are crushing their finances and the specter of foreclosure is looming.”
“The Spendloves bought their modest Nipomo home in 1993 for $153,000, and for almost a decade, everything was fine. Then six years ago, their lives fell into a long downward spiral. Don was at work one night in early June 2001 when a fire broke out in the 26-acre complex housing California Giant Strawberries.”
“‘We knew he’d be out of work for a time, so we refinanced and put some money away,’ Rebecca said. ‘When that was gone, we refinanced again. We had no idea (his disability) would be a permanent situation.’”
“When the refinance terms were set, the Spendloves found their payments would jump from $1,400 a month to $2,600 a month. ‘As we were doing the paperwork, I told them the payments were too much,’ she said. ‘They said, ‘No, you’ve got the income, and you’ll be paying off your credit cards. It worked out fine on paper.’”
“The Spendloves had also asked for $4,000 from the refinancing, Rebecca said, but the company convinced them to take $35,000. As it turned out, ‘We used that money to pay the mortgage,’ she said. ‘And our credit cards all went up again,’ Don added.”
“In a bid to make ends meet, the Spendloves emptied two bedrooms and rented them out. ‘We have no life, we have no privacy,’ Rebecca said. Rebecca also started selling Avon. She sold all her jewelry. They sold everything they could on eBay and in yard sales.”
“‘We bought this house for $153,000,’ she said. ‘Now we owe $416,000. Granted, we refinanced a couple of times, but we had equity, the market was good.’”
“‘If we could sell the house, they’d get their money,’ Don said, shaking his head. ‘We’ll have to walk away. I don’t know why they can’t understand this.’”
“Just across their street, a home has sat vacant for more than a year, the yard untended, the windows coated with dust. ‘Our neighbor … just walked away,’ said Don. ‘He said, ‘I’m not paying.’ He just moved away.’”
The Contra Costa Times. “Under water. Upside down. Negative equity. No matter the terminology to describe the erosion of home equity in the East Bay, the conclusion is inescapable: A local housing sector that once was remarkable for how high it could soar has plunged into the depths.”
“About two out of three East Bay homes that were bought since 2005 are now worth less than the mortgages on the houses, according to a Zillow.com study.”
“One Brentwood resident who bought a home in the Garin Ranch section of Brentwood said he and his wife have ridden a roller coaster of home values. Robert, who asked that his last name not be used, said they have been hammered both by falling home values and rising mortgage payments.”
“‘The first year and a half, the house’s value went way up,’ Robert said.”
“In late 2004, Robert and his wife paid $524,500 for the house. Now it’s up for sale for $369,000. A lender for the house, Citibank, has begun foreclosure proceedings on the financially distressed property, county records show.”
“This definitely has a ways to go,’ said Christopher Thornberg, an economist with Beacon Economics. ‘There is no sense this is anywhere close to being over. This thing is not over by any stretch of the imagination.’”
“‘You have the walk-away issue, where people see the house is under water and they give up,’ Thornberg said. ‘People will realize over time that it is ludicrous. They will ask themselves why keep making a mortgage payment.’”
“Robert, the Brentwood resident, said he and his wife are devastated about the prospect of losing their home through the looming foreclosure. He recalls how much time they spent fine-tuning amenities for the residence.”
“‘We picked our own tile and other options,’ Robert said. ‘We loved that house. It killed us to walk away.’”
The Mercury News. “Gregg Winchester and his wife, Cynthia, made an offer on the 2,430-square-foot, four-bedroom, three-bath house the same day they saw it.
“‘We felt now was the time to purchase something for our family now that prices had come down,’ he said. The couple bought the bank-owned house for $355,000.”
“According to the National Association of Home Builders/Wells Fargo Housing Opportunity Index…in the East Bay, 32.4 percent of residents could buy a home in the first part of 2008 as opposed to only 17.4 percent in late 2007. In San Joaquin County, it went from 16.9 percent of people to 35.5 percent, while those on the Peninsula who could afford a home rose from 7.9 percent to 12.7 percent. Solano County’s affordability rose from 20.4 percent to 35.1 percent.”
“Sean O’Toole, CEO of ForeclosureRadar in Discovery Bay, said that 22,324 homes reverted back to the bank in California in April. Of that, 954 were in Contra Costa County.”
“O’Toole, who also invests in real estate, said that the return on investment for buying distressed properties and renting them out is coming close to creating a positive cash flow. ‘We still have some people who are speculating that this is the bottom and they’ll be rich in two years, but those are the same folks who got into trouble the last time.’”
“Perhaps it’s the price drops that are tempting more buyers. Homes that previously were selling for $800,000 can now be bought around $400,000, and although inflated prices were arguably due to a housing bubble, many are still attracted to what they view as a bargain.”
“Bryce Ellsworth, a broker in Brentwood, said that homes that are priced well, especially foreclosures, receive multiple offers. And the majority buying are investors looking for positive cash flow, including himself. ‘Properties are being sold significantly below values. I think I’ll take my chances,’ he said.”
“As the housing slowdown and credit crunch metastasized through the economy, new vehicle sales in the state fell almost 19 percent in 2008’s first quarter compared to 2007’s first quarter, the California Motor Dealers Association said.”
“‘My family has owned this dealership for 71 years,’ said Bill Brunelli, director of operations at Central Chevrolet in Fremont. ‘I’ve been in the business all my life; I remember the oil embargo of the 1970s, and I’ve never seen anything like this. We used to sell 200 cars a month five years ago; now we may sell 20 or 30.’”
“‘Up until last year or so, money was much more free-flowing,’ Brunelli said. ‘Interest rates were very low, and people who typically would not have been approved for loans got approved. Just like the housing industry. If they couldn’t get a car loan they would refinance their house and buy a car.’”
“But now, Brunelli said, ‘lenders have tightened their purse strings and said, ‘No. We would have done it in those days, but that got us into trouble, so we’re not lending to that level any more.’”
From ABC 7.com. “It’s a sign of the times — some very hard times. Bankruptcy filings are up, and in Orange County they are skyrocketing. One development Eyewitness News visited in Orange County is supposed to be a sprawling collection of new houses and townhomes.”
“But the only thing sprawling these days across the empty fields are the weeds. The real estate market is withering.”
“‘You can probably drive around most of Southern California and see real estate development projects that have, frankly, just stopped,’ said bankruptcy attorney Jim Bastian.”
“Bankruptcy filings in Southern California are skyrocketing. The latest year-to-year numbers for April show bankruptcies in L.A. County are up 92 percent. In Riverside County, they’re even worse at 125 percent. In Orange County, statistics show bankruptcies are up a staggering 153 percent.”
“‘It’s going to get worse before it gets better,’ said Bastian. ‘Most of the people that I’ve talked to, and if you talk to experts in the industry, they’ll tell you it might be 2010 or 2011 before we see prices get back to where they were even three or four years ago.’”
“‘People who should not have been in this situation, where they’re buying a $400,000 or $500,000 house and having a mortgage payment of $4,000 or $5,000 per month, when they’re only making $25,000 or $35,000 a year,’ said Bastian.”
“That ultimately leads to bankruptcy court. As visits to court add up, developers work on their subtraction. Earth movers are moving nothing, new streets have no cars and housing lots have lots of nothing. What was once a real estate boom is now an unnerving silence.”
The Capitol Weekly. “The mortgage crisis hasn’t just led to a rising tide of high-profile foreclosures. It has also resulted in a near-flood of mortgage industry-related bills making their way through the Legislature.”
“Beating the deadline for bills to emerge from their house of origin, a trio of Senate bills supported by the California Mortgage Bankers Association had made it out of the Senate. Several other bills the group opposed either died or were amended.”
“Dustin Hobbs, communications director for the CMBA, said…that the subprime crisis has been somewhat overblown in the media, given that 78 percent of Californians who got subprime loans in 2005 and 2006 are still in their homes.”
“‘We don’t want to go back to the days when you had to put 20 percent down,’ Hobbs said.”
The LA Times. “Mortgage delinquencies and foreclosures reached record levels in the first three months of this year, driven higher by increasing housing woes in California and Florida, the Mortgage Bankers Assn. reported today.”
“‘The problems in California and Florida are extraordinary and they are the main drivers of the national trend,’ said Jay Brinkmann, the association’s VP for research and economics.”
“California accounts for 13% of the country’s mortgages outstanding but is responsible for 21% of the homes that entered the foreclosure process in the latest period. The number of foreclosures started was the highest since 1979, as were the percentage of homes in foreclosure and the percentage in delinquency, the association said.”
“Two years ago, Patricia Prado worried that she would never be able to buy a house. Property values in this Central Coast farm town had been rising sharply, and Prado and her husband were burdened by $18,000 in debt from their credit cards and the loan on their Jeep Grand Cherokee.”
“She got a phone call from a mortgage broker who said she had heard her tale and had a solution: a mortgage loan that required no money down. ‘She made everything sound like it was going to be wonderful,’ said Prado.”
“A few weeks later, Prado bought a $412,000 house with a so-called 80/20 mortgage. Those mortgages are actually a pair of loans — one for 80% of the purchase price and another for the remaining 20%.”
“‘In some places, where house prices were running up 20% year over year, you only needed one year of that run-up for the package to become well-collateralized,’ said Stuart Gabriel, a UCLA real estate finance expert. ‘All of that was predicated entirely on the presumption, the expectation, of a continued significant house price run-up.’”
“Property values, of course, began falling sharply last year. And that left people such as Prado, who bought near the top of the market, owing more in loans than their homes were worth. Her home is set to be sold in a foreclosure auction next week.”
“Prado acknowledged that she stated her monthly income as $7,500 on the loan application — nearly double what she was actually earning in her job. Still, she was confident the payments would not be a problem. At the time, her husband was earning $20 an hour as a carpenter as builders turned the area’s broccoli fields into housing developments.”
“By year’s end, home values had flattened out, and then began dropping. That meant Prado would not be able draw on rising equity to refinance her mortgage, as so many planned to do during the real estate boom.”
“As home values plunged, new-home building slowed and her husband lost his job in 2007. Then this year, their monthly payment shot up by $450 to $2,650 as a higher interest rate kicked in, Prado said.”
“Financially, Prado says she hasn’t really lost anything, since she put no money down to get her mortgage. She’s looking for a place to rent. Houses like hers are now renting for between $1,300 to $1,600 a month, Prado said.”
“Her biggest challenge, she said, was trying to keep her children, a 10-year-old boy and 7-year-old girl, from figuring out what happened. To soften the blow to the children, Prado said she told them that they were only renting the home they had bought. In many ways, that’s true.”