The Rational Thing To Do In California
The San Francisco Chronicle reports from California. “In the Bay Area, mortgage companies recorded 18,516 notices of default, up more than 140 percent from a year ago. Foreclosures rose nearly 315 percent to 9,206. As the slowing economy made it more difficult for Carlos Amaya to find regular work as a truck driver, the Amayas fell behind on their payments. The couple remains several payments behind.”
“Representatives of the company have called several times, refused to alter the terms of the loan and threatened to begin foreclosure proceedings, she said. ‘It’s my house, my kids live there,’ said Amaya. ‘I don’t want to leave the house, I love my house, and I’m trying to coordinate with them. Everything is refused when I call.’”
“Banks offering workouts can do only so much to stem climbing foreclosures, said Michael Carney, director of the Real Estate Research Council of Northern California. That’s because plummeting home values often mean borrowers owe much more on their loans then their property is worth, an issue that interest rates can’t address.”
“‘The ethical thing to do is to keep paying on the loan, but the rational thing, if it doesn’t look like your head will be above water soon … is to default,’ he said.”
The Mercury News. “The number of Santa Clara County homeowners who lost their properties to foreclosure last quarter jumped more than 500 percent, while those facing that fate nearly tripled.”
“Marlene Santiago, a foreclosure intervention counselor at Neighborhood Housing Services in San Jose, said about 10 percent of the clients whose loans she submits to lenders for possible modification get approved.”
“Santiago said most of the homeowners she works with now owe more on their mortgages than they could get for their homes. Given that, many would rather stop making their high monthly mortgage payments and find someplace to rent - sometimes at half the cost of their monthly loan obligations.”
The Marin Independent Journal. “Default notices in Marin surged more than 140 percent over the past three months. Marin had 284 recorded notices of default, during the second quarter this year, up from the 118 default notices during the period last year. Statewide, the number of default notices doubled.”
“Marin has posted 702 properties in various stages of foreclosure in the past four months, according to ForeclosureRadar. Nearly half of those properties - 337 - are in Novato, with San Rafael accounting for 193 distressed homes.”
The Press Democrat. “Lenders seized a record 788 homes in foreclosure in Sonoma County during the second quarter, up 46 percent from the first quarter and nearly five times the total from a year ago, DataQuick reported. Every week, lenders took back more than 60 homes from borrowers who had stopped paying their mortgages.”
“Sonoma County’s housing market is saturated with bank-owned properties and by homeowners who are attempting to sell and avoid foreclosure. ‘I have never seen this many of them in the 20 years I’ve been in this business. There appears to be no change in the immediate horizon,’ said John Binns, a CPS agent specializing in selling bank-owned homes.”
“Every week, more than 100 borrowers in Sonoma County fell behind on payments or stopped paying mortgages, triple the number from a year ago.”
“‘Generally the banks try to price properties at market because they’re always taking massive, massive losses on these properties,’ Binns said. ‘We’ve seen a very dramatic decline in pricing. It took place fairly rapidly as opposed to being drawn out over several years.’”
The Sacramento Bee. “Foreclosures again climbed sharply in the area during April, May and June as 6,075 more households handed keys back to the banks. The new numbers mean that 21,402 homes have been foreclosed on in the region since January 2007, according to DataQuick.”
“‘We’re not seeing it slacken off at all,’ said Pam Canada, executive director of Sacramento’s NeighborWorks HomeOwnership Center.”
“Mike Lyon, head of Sacramento-based Lyon Real Estate, still worries about a coming wave of higher-end foreclosures tied to ‘Alt-A’ loans, a category between prime and the riskier subprime loans. Many of those loans involve houses worth $350,000 to $750,000.”
“‘A lot of people won’t qualify for that,’ he said. ‘There’s the potential pileup.’”
The Tracy Press. “Kim and Juliet Chapman earned a combined $120,000 income last year. Finances were in order until Juliet was laid off from her bank job in March, after 20 years in the business. Now, it’s up to Kim to pay the bills with the $60,000 annual salary he earns as a San Mateo County employee - exactly half what the couple used to make.”
“At the same time, their home’s value has dropped drastically since they bought it in 2005. Then they took out a second mortgage last year to help with their son’s wedding.”
“Now, they’re too deep in the hole to think of a way out. ‘Things have drastically changed,’ he said, citing burgeoning gas and food prices and a $3,400 monthly mortgage payment as ample reason to contemplate Chapter 11 as a way out.”
“‘We’re thinking of retiring and starting over somewhere else,’ he said, ‘probably in another state.’”
The Monterey County Herald. “Foreclosures in Monterey County continue to climb at a record pace, with 847 homes lost to foreclosure in the second quarter, reflecting an increase of 443 percent over the second quarter of 2007. Notices of default rose by almost 287 percent, said DataQuick.”
“Sandy Haney, CEO of the Monterey County Association of Realtors, said it isn’t surprising that the coastal regions are showing increased default notices and foreclosures. ‘Your coastal regions are always more expensive,’ said Haney, ‘and people sometimes stretch to live there.’”
“Monterey County’s rising numbers may reflect another trend: a delayed reaction as stretched homeowners who initially tried to hang onto their properties decide to throw in the towel.”
“‘I think there’s been a mindset,’ said Haney. ‘A lot of people are walking away because it seems like the thing to do, because they can.’”
“But inventories remain high. At the end of June, there were 2,768 homes on the market in Monterey County, and distressed sales continue to drive down median home prices.’
“‘The deeper we get into this and the deeper the economy goes, their fingernails get short,’ said Haney. ‘They can’t hang on any longer.’”
“In the lower end of the market, where the distressed properties are concentrated, some brokers are beginning to see multiple offers again. Anything in between - the $500,000 to $900,000 range - is in what she calls ‘the no-man’s land.’”
“‘We woke up one morning,’ said Haney, ‘and it looked different.’”
The Union Tribune. “Distressed mortgages continued to drag on the troubled economy in June, as a record number of homes in San Diego County went into foreclosure. Mark Goldman, who teaches real estate finance at San Diego State University, said lenders are awakening to the realization that they need to modify more loans to keep the shaky home-mortgage system from collapsing.”
“Countywide, nearly 40 percent of all homes sold in June had been foreclosed on within the previous 12 months, he said. In neighborhoods where vacant, bank-owned homes dot the landscape, the figure can exceed 50 percent.”
“‘I think we’re seeing more mitigation,’ he said. ‘I think the lenders are so inundated with properties they are becoming more open to modifications and forbearances.’”
The Orange County Register. “John and Grayce Coffman got a killer deal on their Fullerton home’s mortgage - just 1 percent interest for five years. It came after six months of complex, sometimes contradictory, negotiations with the nation’s largest home lender to avoid foreclosure. They couldn’t afford their previous loan.”
“Most borrowers probably can’t get as sweet a deal as the Coffmans. The reason: it was a mistake. It meant to offer 1 percent for the first year, with the rate increasing one percentage point for each of the next four years. It later decided to honor the error.”
“In an emailed statement, the company said: ‘A clerical mistake was made on the loan modification documents in favor of the Coffmans. Since it was our mistake and the erroneous documents had been signed, we are honoring the rate and modification terms for the full five years.’”
“The couple, who have owned their home since 1977, borrowed $552,300 from Countrywide in the summer of 2005. They got a loan that allowed them to select their monthly payment from four options. They repeatedly chose the cheapest option, which meant the balance they owed the bank grew.”
“By fall 2007, their debt to Countrywide had increased nearly $40,000. The Coffmans, who adopted six grandchildren (five still live with them) and are unemployed, admit they fumbled their finances. They refinanced several times, taking money out of their home and spending it on remodeling the house and on living expenses.”
“But they also said they were misled by Countrywide into a complex loan they didn’t understand - a charge the company disputes.”
“‘I have accepted 50 percent of the responsibility,’ Grayce Coffman said. ‘”But the other 50 percent? No way. These people knew what they were doing.’”
The Wall Street Journal. “As lenders rush to curtail their real-estate exposure and preserve sorely needed capital, they are triggering lawsuits from builders that say the banks have unfairly cut off their construction financing, stopped their projects midstream and forced their companies to the brink of bankruptcy.”
“‘Lender-liability lawsuits are coming. It’s only just beginning,’ says Michael Hackard, a lawyer in Sacramento, Calif.”
“Developer John Thomas says he had nearly finished building a 222-unit condominium and hotel project in Stockton, Calif., when his lender wouldn’t release the final $6 million from his $40 million construction loan.”
“The bank indicated on ‘multiple occasions’ that it would finish funding the loan, but never did, according to a lawsuit Mr. Thomas’s company filed against First Bank in Superior Court in Sacramento County. As a result, Mr. Thomas’s lawyer says, liens have piled up against the project, the condo units haven’t been completed, and the hotel has been taken over by a receiver.”
“J.P. Eliopulos Enterprises Inc., a home builder in the hard-hit housing market of California’s Antelope Valley, north of Los Angeles, is suing IndyMac Bancorp Inc. which is now under federal control.”
“The bank appraisal in December 2007 valued the project, the approximately 900-acre Joshua Ranch Development, at $17 million, down from an appraised value of $82 million in May of that year, says Andrew Eliopulos, the company’s CEO.”
“The bank estimated it would take about 18 years to sell 539 houses on the property, Mr. Eliopulos said.
That’s insane, he said. ‘I told them your appraisal is flawed. This bank is in trouble, and it just wants out.’”
“He says the bank had been pursuing personal guarantees that he, his wife and his 81-year-old mother signed when the builder took out the loans. IndyMac had been requiring that the builder pay the difference between the property’s $17 million appraised value and the $27 million loan balance, or pay off the loan in full, he says.”
“‘If banks want to get out of residential lending, that’s fine; let’s sit down and figure it out,’ says Mick Pattinson, CEO of builder Barratt American, based in Carlsbad, Calif. ‘But that isn’t being done. The rug is literally being pulled from under us and games are being played.’”
“Mr. Pattinson says Bank of America Corp. froze his $100 million credit line for seven months, while ordering a new appraisal of his properties. During that time, Mr. Pattinson says, his company paid down its credit line by $30 million, but then stopped making payments in March when Mr. Pattinson says he realized the bank was never going to unfreeze the loan.”
“Mr. Pattinson says that ‘after seven months, this country boy figured they weren’t going to allow us to use the credit line. I said, ‘No functioning line, no interest.’”
The Bakersfield Californian. “Two homebuilders unloaded residential tracts in Bakersfield last month for substantially less than they paid at the height of the boom, county records show.”
“The fire-price sales indicate some developers might be willing or eager to trim portfolios as land value here declines - declines that will be tallied in a matter of weeks, a county assessment official said.”
“Ennis Homes Inc., a regional builder based in Porterville, sold two southwest parcels for less than $1.5 million, county records show. Ennis bought the land in 2005 in a pair of transactions totaling more than $8.2 million.”
“KB Home, a national builder headquartered in Los Angeles, sold a northeast parcel for $765,000, records show. The company bought the land for more than $3.3 million in 2005. It’s at least the third such transaction locally since the market slipped.”
“The office is currently revaluing raw land and residential subdivisions held mostly by developers, said Tony Ansolabehere, assistant assessor. He expects ‘hundreds and hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of property value to be shaved from the roll in the next few weeks.”
“Land that fetched up to $200,000 an acre during the peak is worth … well, it’s hard to figure, he said. If someone can get $50,000 an acre now, ‘they’re doing good,’ he said.”
“Some parcels valued at $20,000 an acre before the market run-up could sink back to that pre-boom value, he said.”
“‘Land prices have really fallen,’ he said, noting banks have foreclosed on vacant tracts and unfinished subdivisions, bringing down value further.”