They Just Plain Walk Away In California
The BBC News reports on California. “In May 2006, at the height of the housing boom, Karen Trainer bought a $500,000 apartment in California - with money borrowed from her bank. By this year, Karen still owed $500,000 on her mortgage, but her apartment was worth $200,000 less. So she was deep in negative equity and, to make matters worse, the interest rate on her loan was about to increase. ‘I thought ‘this is crazy,’ Ms Trainer says. ‘It just does not make financial sense.’”
“As a successful professional, Karen could comfortably have managed the higher mortgage payments her bank demanded. Instead, she decided to stop her mortgage payments altogether and let her bank repossess her apartment.”
“‘Generally speaking, within 5 years you are about back where you were, so my husband and I decided we’ll take the hit and live with it,’ she said.”
“‘This is the kind of conversation that’s going on at cocktail parties, at swimming pools,’ Professor Susan Wachter, professor of real estate and finance at Wharton School of Business says. ‘And suddenly this option which was truly unthinkable in the past becomes thinkable.’”
“Ms Trainer says she feels no moral obligation to go on paying a loan on a property that is going to go on losing her money. She says her friends support her decision. ‘I think people are taking a more cold-hearted look at it,’ she says. ‘Is the bank going to pay for my retirement because I was a good girl and paid my mortgage, even though legally I didn’t have to?’”
“In the city of Stockton - the foreclosure, or repossession, capital of the US for 2007 - estate agent Kevin Morgan sells repossessed houses on behalf of the banks that now own them. According to him, walking away has become commonplace.”
“‘I would say it’s probably 70% of the volume of our foreclosures right now,’ he says. ‘It’s a business decision for their family that the smartest thing they can do is walk away from their home.’”
“As a sign of the changing times, some 60% of borrowers do not even bother to contact their banks to attempt a renegotiation of their loan, Mr Moran explains. ‘They stop paying and they stop talking,’ he says. ‘They just plain walk away.’”
The North County Times. “San Diego County house prices fell by the largest margin yet, tumbling 23 percent from a year ago, according to a report released Tuesday. Year-over-year declines in San Diego County were the steepest on record for the index, which goes back to 1987.”
“House prices approached a 30 percent overall decline, down 28.9 percent from a November 2005 peak. Still, house prices are 78 percent higher than 2000 levels, according to the report.”
“Including inflation, house prices are 35.1 percent below the 2005 peak and just 38.7 percent above 2000 levels.”
“Low-end real estate, below $372,135, led the price decline for the 15th straight month. But for the first time in seven months, high-end houses, defined as those selling for more than $552,477, lost more in one month than the middle-tier, or those priced above $372,135.”
“That high-end houses declined at a faster rate ‘is not surprising, particularly now that we’re two years into a general decline,’ said Maureen Maitland, VP of index analysis. ‘It just shows the demographics of the market decline moving around.’”
The Press Enterprise. “A US. District Court judge on Monday set an Aug. 18, 2009, trial date for three Murrieta men that the Securities and Exchange Commission has accused of operating a real estate scam that defrauded at least 95 investors of more than $11 million and forced many into foreclosure.”
“Judge Virginia A. Phillips chose that date to hear the SEC case that accuses James B. Duncan, Hendrix Montecastro and Maurice E. McLeod of violating federal securities laws and seeks civil penalties and restitution of ‘ill-gotten gains’ derived from the scheme.”
“Also named as defendants are Pacific Wealth Management, Stonewood Consulting Inc. and Total Return Fund, all companies that Duncan, Montecasto and McLeod controlled.”
“The SEC lawsuit said Duncan and his colleagues solicited investors in Southern California and elsewhere who wanted to benefit from the Southern California real estate boom a few years ago. The scheme targeted military personnel at Davis-Monthan Air Force Base in Tucson, Ariz., as well as the Southern California Filipino community and church members.”
“Duncan, Montecastro and McLeod are accused of directing investors to purchase more than $118 million worth of homes, falsifying loan applications so they would afford to buy multiple houses. According to the lawsuit, the defendants would obtain an inflated appraisal on the houses and pay themselves a fee from the excess mortgage proceeds.”
“The complaint said the defendants agreed to make the monthly mortgage payments on the houses only to entice other investors. When the mortgage payments ultimately stopped amid a cooling real estate market, the investment houses fell into foreclosure.”
“About 20 angry investors, wearing distinctive orange t-shirts, attended Monday’s hearing. One of them, James Lheureux, said he believes the defendants have been able to hire ‘high-priced lawyers’ with the victims’ money and he would like to see them prosecuted criminally. ‘We are looking to put them in jail,’ he said.”
The Bakersfield Californian. “The hearing of state accusations against former Bakersfield real estate firm Crisp, Cole & Associates got off to a quiet start Monday in the basement of the Masonic Temple downtown.”
“Regulators say the company lied to lenders on more than $12 million worth of loans. As the designated broker, Cole was responsible for the activities of the company and its staff at all times, the complaint says.”
“Cole’s attorney, Glenn Kottcamp of Fresno, said his client had little to do with the transactions in the California Department of Real Estate’s 25-page complaint, filed last September.”
“In 2005, Kottcamp said, when most of the transactions took place, Cole’s attention was consumed by plans to erect giant towers at Cal State Bakersfield. The towers project later collapsed from lack of funding.”
“‘He didn’t know’ what Crisp & Cole employees were up to at the time, Kottcamp said. David Crisp, 28, a licensed sales agent, served as his own counsel.”
“Cole’s attorney implied Crisp had forged Cole’s signature on one set of documents. The judge ended the line of questioning when the state’s attorney objected.”
“Crisp was mostly quiet, but became bolder in cross-examining witnesses toward the end of the session. In one instance, he attempted to question underwriting standards of Fremont Investment & Loan, but was cut off by an objection.”
“The judge seemed to offer good-natured advice about the need to establish a line of questioning before Crisp could ask such questions of the Fremont witness, Laura Calmes.”
“Former Crisp & Cole employee Robinson Nguyen did not appear Monday. He will lose his license by default when the proceedings end, said Rich, the state attorney. Two other employees named in the complaint made deals prior to the hearing.”
“The downtown vintage shop Shabby Chic has closed its doors after eight years so that the owners can concentrate on another store. Shabby Chic is the latest in a string of downtown retailers that have closed in recent months, most of them casualties of a slow economy. ‘It was doing well, it’s just that we’ve opened another business and wanted to focus on that,’ (co-owner) Kelli Davis said. ‘We just didn’t want to deal with it anymore.’”
“Bambini Carini, a retailer of children’s furniture and apparel at 19th and Eye Streets, closed a few weeks ago.” Neighbor Jezabelle’s Unique Boutique is for sale. Owner Mario Delis said he put it on the market to focus on other business interests.”
“It’s not that downtown is weak, insisted Bakersfield Economic Development Director Donna Kunz. ‘Anything, anywhere, that is a high-end boutique or housing-related is really having a troublesome time right now because of the residential market,’ she said. ‘Between fuel costs and food prices, people just don’t have a lot to spend right now.’”
“‘”Unfortunately downtown doesn’t have that many, so when we lose even one there it’s kind of tragic. Hopefully our restaurants will be able to keep things going until our Mill Creek project gets going,’ she said.”
“The 10-acre South Mill Creek project is a mix of 85 high-rise apartments, 35 condos and 65,000 square feet of neighborhood shops and restaurants.”
The Desert Sun. “The Coachella Valley needs to go after higher-paying jobs, particularly in the health care industry, to diversify its economic base, a national community and economic development consultant said Monday.”
“The desert has ‘enviable assets,’ yet there are ‘troublesome trends’ when it comes to its decline in labor force participation and economic mix, said J. Mac Holladay, CEO of Atlanta-based Market Street Services.”
“‘We have never had, in the history of this country, this set of circumstances at the same time,’ he said, referring to the high prices of oil and food housing values as well as drops in home values, construction and jobs that plague the nation’s economy. ‘It is time for you to get very, very serious about this.’”
“The idea of regional economic development and stimulus is gaining steam among a number of local agencies, including the desert chapter of the Building Industry Association of Southern California, which helped sponsor Monday’s event.”
“‘We’re shifting gears to try to stimulate economic conversations that we have not had in the past and have not been required during economic booms,’ association executive director Fred Bell said.”