“We Have To Pay The Price For The Great Gains”
The Press Enterprise reports from California. “Inland home foreclosures this year have increased more than ninefold over the same period a year ago, driven by flat appreciation and sagging home sales. Ana Ibarra and her husband, Guillermo Macias, adore their five-bedroom house in a new tract of executive-style homes in north Fontana.”
“But Ibarra said the couple doesn’t have enough money to furnish the house. Ibarra said she and Macias, a 30-year-old commercial plumber, together earn about $5,400 a month after taxes. Since moving into their new house in December, they have spent $4,000 a month of that on the house’s interest-only mortgage, property taxes and homeowner insurance.”
“They have wiped out their savings. What’s more, they are responsible for a $2,000-a-month mortgage payment on another house they own in south Fontana. They rent that three-bedroom house.”
“Ibarra said after they signed an agreement with Lennar Homes for the house in north Fontana and made a deposit, they learned their first house had not appreciated enough to help them pay for a second one. She said they tried to back out of the purchase but were reminded they had signed a contract.”
“‘We are really not buying. We are just paying interest and we are in debt for almost $1 million,’ Ibarra said.”
“Ibarra said while she and her husband are responsible for their predicament, so is Lennar’s lender. ‘It was their fault. They just wanted to sell. They should not have approved us,’ Ibarra said. ‘We just jumped at the opportunity because we thought it was going to be easy, as easy as getting the loan.’”
The Napa Valley Register. “Are the 88 notices of foreclosure in the first quarter of this year in Napa, nearly twice as many as a year ago. John Mourraille, a mortgage broker/owner in St. Helena, said any foreclosure in any neighborhood affects values of surrounding homes.”
“Mourraille predicts things will get worse before getting better. ‘In the past five years everything was going up in value in the 20 percent plus range, nothing like it in real estate history and now that’s over. We have to pay the price for the great gains,’ Mourraille said.”
“‘The next seven years will be a time of correction. We are just beginning the cycle. Real estate pretty much runs in a seven-year cycle,’ Mourraille said. ‘And the correction will be across the board, including the multi-million dollar estates.’”
The Record Spotlight. “The number of homes in some stage of foreclosure in Shasta County in the first quarter of 2007 more than doubled from a year ago.”
“‘The subprime market has all but gone away. We are in such an uproar right now,’ north state mortgage loan officer Sue Gabrielson in Redding said. ‘I don’t know what they (subprime lenders) thought was going to happen.’”
“The subprime meltdown means 100 percent financing is likely to be available only to borrowers who have excellent credit, Gabrielson said. ‘Depending on the severity of the rate of loan defaults, it may have a significant impact on our local housing valuations,’ Gabrielson said.”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “Business is brisk for lawyer Pamela Simmons. The number of calls from desperate homeowners has reached about 100 a month, she said, as the rapid appreciation that fueled the housing market in the early part of the decade has slowed to a crawl and the adjustable interest rates on loans taken out in those heady times are starting to rise.”
“‘I used to do one of these cases every three months,’ Simmons said. ‘Now, it’s all I do.’”
“Melissa Pacheco and her husband, Carlos, wanted to own their own home, so much so that they were willing to take a subprime loan at about 9 percent interest and make $6,000-per-month payments to buy a three-bedroom house in Soquel for $475,000 in 2004. They put no money down.”
“The Pachecos decided to refinance. The appraisal for the new loan put the house’s worth at $760,000, nearly $300,000 more than the Pachecos paid a year earlier. They also wanted to take some cash out of the house.”
“By the time the Pachecos’ statement arrived last month, the loan balance was $629,406.84. The interest rate, which began rising just 38 days after the loan was issued, had climbed to 8.375 percent.”
The Union Tribune. “According to the FBI, 80 percent of all reported fraud losses involve collaboration by industry insiders, such as brokers, appraisers and agents. The lender typically is a victim.”
“‘A year and two years ago we had unnaturally low foreclosure activity because we had unnaturally high appreciation,’ researcher John Karevoll of DataQuick said. ‘As the tide goes out now, we are seeing a lot of nastiness that was below the surface.’”
“‘Last year we saw a lot of it,’ said David Cabot, president of the San Diego Association of Realtors, who oversees more than 100 Prudential real estate offices in Southern California. ‘There were a dozen times when I was getting calls from managers or agents in my company. You know on the surface that (the loan) doesn’t seem legitimate.’”
“Cabot said his employees were reporting offers where ‘the buyer would get a hunk of money directly from the seller after the close of escrow to inflate the purchase price, then get an appraiser to appraise at the higher amount. None of it included informing the lender.’”
“C. Robert Simpson, an attorney who specializes in recovering mortgage fraud loss, said underwriting standards need to be much tighter. ‘We, as an industry, have ceased telling people, ‘You are not qualified.’ he said. ‘We will give loans to anyone for any purpose.’”
The Daily Bulletin. “What’s really happening in the housing market, particularly in the Inland Empire? Is it a good time to buy? A good time to sell? A good time to wait, or just a good time to weep?”
“Bruce Norris, a veteran observer of the scene, points out that every down cycle in California’s real estate market started when affordability dipped to 17 percent. It happened in 1980 and it happened again in 1989, but Norris thinks the problem is even greater this time.”
“‘It’s bad enough that we’ve reached the 17percent affordability rate,’ he writes. ‘The real problem is how we got there this time.’”
“In 1980, affordability dipped to where it did because mortgage rates climbed to 16 percent. In 1989, mortgages cost 10 percent. This time, interest rates were low enough that people were spending nine times their annual income on the price of a house.”
“‘Unsold inventory has grown by more than 100 percent in one year,’ Norris writes. ‘Thus far, there has been limited price damage because almost all of the properties for sale have been privately owned.’”
“‘In 2007, that will change. The new inventory for sale will consist of lender-owned properties, builder auctions and short sales. All of these sellers will be selling to a less-motivated, smaller group of less-able-to-qualify buyers,’ Norris said.”
“Why is it that the market can feel like it’s dropping, with homes for sale for longer stretches and the number of sold homes down significantly, yet published prices either remain the same or continue climbing?”
“John Husing, a regional economist based in Redlands, says it’s possible home prices, at least in part of the market, might actually be declining.”
“‘We use the median to determine housing prices,’ Husing said. ‘There’s a feeling that averaging prices would distort things because of the high end of the market.’”
“‘What we have now is a market where the bottom half of the market is strong and the top half weaker,’ Husing said. ‘So the way we measure housing prices might actually be hiding a decline in the top end of the market.’”