Now The Slide Has Become Reality
It’s desk clearing time for this blogger. “As Miami’s unofficial prophet of doom during a condo bubble that is no longer in dispute, I wrote column after column counseling caution rather than unbridled euphoria. Now the slide has become reality, Miami’s condo-construction wave is about to end, and completed units will soon hit the closing table. I’m no longer in the minority talking bubbles — but on the plus side, I’m also not alone in seeing value in the bubble.”
“More than two years ago, when Florida International University sponsored a panel on downtown housing’s spurt, then-City Commissioner Johnny Winton was asked whether a bust would follow. He had advice for developers: ‘Build ‘em. If they fail, we’re going to end up with affordable housing.’”
“Two years to go until Florida’s housing construction returns to 2001 levels, the eve of the state’s most recent housing boom. So says Sean Snaith, University of Central Florida’s Institute for Economic Competitiveness director.”
“Snaith, you see, is generally critical of those use the word ‘bubble’ regarding Florida’s housing market and, more specifically, those who say it has or is on the verge of bursting.”
“‘It is well know that they have egos larger than an NFL player’s rap sheet,’ Snaith tosses barbs in his study at those professional and amateur forecasters who make dire predictions about housing.”
“In writing about the housing market in the past, I’ve tried to be relatively balanced. Yes, I’ve aired my concerns, but I’ve generally tempered them in various ways. Maybe I pulled too many punches.”
“It became obvious that rental prices were not rising in proportion to sale prices or appraised values. On my block, a house consisting of three rental units sold last year for $380,000. Granted, it’s in better shape than it was in 2000, when it sold for $108,000. But not that much better shape.”
“More significantly, the three units will probably at best generate about $2,500 a month in rental income for the foreseeable future. Right now, however, the total income is considerably less, especially considering that one of the three units is vacant. So how is that house a good investment? The numbers just don’t add up.”
“About 150 real estate agents and brokers camped out, some for more than 24 hours, for the chance to buy units at a much-hyped waterfront condo in a waiting game some called ’survival of the fittest.’”
“The camp-out, an increasingly common sight at some well marketed condo projects, is a sign that Toronto’s real estate market is not slowing down even as the housing recession deepens in the U.S.”
“Some analysts have been warning that over the past year or so the market has seen an influx of investor. One big risk is that a downturn in the market can cause investors to panic and start dumping their units, causing a price drop. ‘Investors are out in force, sowing their own future disappointment’ said Toronto analyst Will Dunning.”
“Again and again in these past few months, financial markets have appeared to be on the verge of something very scary. During each of these episodes, the financial pages filled with fret: Would this be the moment when markets turned south, when credit dried up, when hedge-fund managers and private-equity partners started applying for work at Wal-Mart?”
“Something with far more impact on most Americans’ lives than a stock-market correction has already happened. That something is the close of a remarkable era of easy money. If you are stuck with an ARM that’s about to reset or have been relying on home-equity loans to make ends meet, you may be in trouble.”
“D.R. Horton executives had braced for a poor spring, normally the best time of year to sell houses, but the results in the April-June quarter were even weaker than expected.”
“‘It is now clear that the selling season did not materialize this year,’ said Horton’s CEO, Donald J. Tomnitz, adding that it was unclear when a housing recovery would begin. ‘We don’t see one on the horizon.’”
“One impact of the continuing housing slump is that people find themselves owning homes they can’t really afford. But how do you know before you buy?”
“Newlyweds Sean and Susan McDonald are shopping for their first house. (They) were surprised at how much a bank was willing to lend them. ‘Then Sean did some number-crunching and realized we can’t afford a monthly payment like that,’ says Susan.”
“‘About one-third of your income devoted to all your housing costs is a very good rule of thumb,’ economist Mark Zandi says. The good news is that Zandi predicts prices will continue to fall until housing becomes more affordable for first-time buyers like the McDonalds.”
“Century 21 Real Estate’s CEO Thomas Kunz may have unintentionally hit the nail on the head when he declared that a ‘pity party’ is gripping the housing industry right now.”
“As this punishing, steep decline has taken hold, everyone from home builder CEOs to real-estate agents to mortgage lenders can’t get over the turn of events. At an auction of townhouses near Fort Myers, Fla., last month, homeowners who had bought into a development built by Levitt and Sons for $300,000 watched as neighboring properties sold for $145,000.”
“‘They promised us that they were not going to go below the market value,’ said one of the homeowners, in a newscast . ‘This is not fair,’ said another.”
“Century 21’s Kunz is fed up with that feel-bad-for-me camp. He hears that kind of talk every day, from buyers, sellers, agents, managers, brokers and more who are angry and confused by how things have turned out.”
“What I am seeing out there is a pity party for everyone involved in real-estate transactions,’ Kunz said.”
“In the end, though, he and everyone else in housing industry must fess up that they are reaping what they sowed. That’s little solace for home owners under water or facing foreclosures. But that’s the way markets work.”
“There is hope! Earlier this week, The Times’ front page screamed, ‘Foreclosures in state hit record high.’ Indeed, Los Angeles County’s foreclosures in the second quarter this year topped out at a whopping 2,581, up more than 700% from that same period last year. Inland Empire counties had it much worse.”
“So why the upbeat interpretation of such a sad story? With potential buyers having a few choices, home prices stand to fall (albeit modestly) to levels that aren’t insane.”
“Painful as it is, the only way that can happen is for the housing market to correct itself and reverse part of the bubble, and that means more foreclosures.”
“For now my wife and I will just have to drive past those desperate for-sale signs that scream, ‘Price reduced!’ In the meantime, we’ll ponder how aggressively we’d like to renegotiate our rent.”