A Housing Bust In California
The Mercury News reports from California. “The seekers boarded the bus Saturday, questions on their minds and dollar signs in their eyes. Possibilities abounded in South San Jose, where numerous ‘for sale’ signs dot the lawns. Again and again the bus stopped at select houses where the tenants had left and foreclosure auctions failed, leaving lenders to repossess the homes.”
“‘You can make steal deals,’ advised broker Don Crozier, as he stood in front of the bus, microphone in hand, ‘even though it’s already below market.’”
“From San Diego to Stockton to San Jose, members of the real estate industry are offering such bus tours to entice home sales in a bad market. ‘Sometimes to get people to move off the dime, you have to have something more than the norm,’ Crozier told the Mercury News before the tour. ‘What do you need to do to snap people out of the little cocoon? Let’s get people on the bus.’”
“Each flaw, said contractor Rick Steiner, was a chance to haggle with the banks holding the mortgages on these empty shells. Take the trim cream-colored home on Goldfield Drive, the one with a market value of $640,000 that’s listed for $575,000.”
“If the tiled pool in the back yard isn’t cracked, Steiner estimates it’ll take $15,000 to get the house up to shape, but he could probably persuade that bank to cut the price by $40,000.”
“The last home on the tour was a townhouse on Communications Hill, turnkey ready with hardwood floors, rich brown carpeting and $70,000 under market.”
“Susi Steiner nodded approvingly. The ‘budding real estate investor’ was looking for a home for her mother and a possible investment for herself and her husband.”
“Standing in the immaculate master bedroom with its walk-in closet, she noted, ‘This is a great thing for my mom because she wants it live-in ready, and I don’t want her to pay full price.’”
“‘It’s a buyers’ market,’ said Cecilia Manibo, whose financial planner advised her to buy real estate. A tour was the most efficient strategy. ‘If we were left on our own,’ she said, ‘we probably wouldn’t do it.’”
From KSND TV. “In 2005, Marty Ummel and her husband bought a four-bedroom house in Carlsbad for $1.2 million. The Ummels say their agent was dishonest about the price of other homes in the neighborhood, and then rushed them to close the deal before the Ummels found out comparable houses on the same street sold for as much as $175,000 less.”
“She has now filed suit against her real estate agent, claiming fraud. ‘We feel that we were misled. We feel disappointed. We do feel angry,’ she said.”
“But in a deposition, an expert witness hired by the defense said of the Ummels: ‘They simply didn’t do what is expected of a knowledgeable sophisticated buyer, and are now looking for someone other than themselves to take responsibility.’”
“People in the real estate industry are calling this a ‘landmark lawsuit.’”
“The National Association Of Realtors said it has failed to find any legal cases in the past five years that revolve solely around the question of valuation. The Ummels’ case goes to trial in Vista on Monday.”
The Voice of San Diego. “Economic disquiet means fewer sales in the city’s stores and restaurants, funneling less general sales tax money to city coffers. Without the confidence boost instilled by a sizzling housing market, a weekend trip out for a flat-screen television or a new couch is less and less common for shoppers in Lemon Grove.”
“And so, Lemon Grove’s Graham Mitchell and the other city managers and financial officials for San Diego County’s 18 cities grapple with sales tax revenues that hardly resemble the economic boom time in recent years. And even among cities whose managers thought they were being quite conservative with revenue projections, some find themselves lowering their expectations.”
“The trouble has hit El Cajon’s car dealerships and Lemon Grove’s home improvement stores. San Marcos’s building permit fees have dropped, and Chula Vista’s new mall hasn’t magnetized the hordes of shoppers envisioned.”
“‘The slumping housing market and drop in consumer confidence has a very direct effect on cities in California,’ said Rod Gould, city manager in Poway. ‘I don’t think any will be exempt from this economic malaise.’”
“Officials in the city of El Cajon last week warned its City Council and mayor of ‘an impending fiscal emergency.’We’ve known that we’ve had this imbalance for a long time, and I think we were all hopeful that the sales tax revenue would go up,’ said Mike Shelton, El Cajon’s finance director. ‘But not only did the economy not get better, it got worse.’”
“Haynes said even though the housing price drops have been very slight in some neighborhoods, many city residents have been hit psychologically.”
“‘There may be something to be said for the decline in prices hitting people psychologically,’ Haynes said. ‘Where they used to feel a little bit more insulated, now [they're saying], ‘Maybe now’s not the best time to go out and make a big purchase.’”
“‘People are people, and they’re going to have to buy a new car eventually,’ said El Cajon’s mayor, Mark Lewis. ‘But you’re seeing if you can make a coat go another year, asking, ‘Do we really need to go out to eat again?’”
The Daily News. “Already grappling with a regional economic squeeze, consumers shivered with concern again last week as news of a possible U.S. recession rippled through the San Fernando Valley.”
“Making money is arguably hardest in the state’s housing market. While 4,935 new homes were built in the San Fernando Valley in 2006, just a year later 1,500 fewer homes were constructed, Blake said.”
“And the slip has given way to job loss in the construction industry, where about 6,200 jobs in housing-related industries were lost in December, according to the California Employment Development Department.”
“‘We don’t call it a housing crisis in the construction industry; we call it a housing bust,’ said Bill Davis, executive VP of the Southern California Contractors Association.”
“‘It’s ugly, bad, horrible - it depends on how dependent you were on the housing business as to which one of those adjectives you’d use,’ Davis said. ‘But it’s just plain not good.’”
“Sales of big-ticket items such as vehicles also are taking a hit, with the California Motor Car Dealers Association saying sales last year dropped 8 percent, the worst in eight years. Hummer sales dropped about 41 percent in 2007.”
“‘I think with all the news we’ve heard about the subprime mortgage (crisis), people are seeing they have less equity in their homes,’ said Crystal Jack, spokeswoman for the association. ‘When you see less equity, you feel less able to make those bigger-ticket purchases.’”
From CBS News. “Stockton is a city of 280,000 people in the Central Valley. A few years ago, it was one of the hottest real estate markets in the country; today it is the foreclosure capital of America.”
“As of last week, there were 4,200 Stockton homes either in default or foreclosure; $1.4 billion in bad loans in just one California community, and it is far from over.”
“Matt and Stephanie Valdez say they knew exactly what they were doing when they bought a small two-bedroom for $355,000. They…planned to refinance the mortgage before the interest rate jumped to 11 percent. But they couldn’t do it because the value of the house had fallen below what they owed on the mortgage. They say they can afford the higher payments, but see no point in making them.”
“‘The house keeps going down, payments keep going up. Where’s the logic in that? And how can we fix it? I mean, that’s what this whole thing’s about for us is how can we fix this? And if we can’t fix it, then what do we do?’ Matt Valdez asks.”
“‘Why pay a $3,200 payment on a 1200-square-foot home? It makes no sense,’ Stephanie Valdez adds.”
“‘That’s what you agreed to do when you bought the house,’ correspondent Steve Kroft points out.”
“‘Fine. If the value is going up. But we’re not going anywhere. The price or the value is going down. It makes no sense because we will never be able to refinance and get a lower payment. There’s no way,’ Stephanie Valdez replies.”
“Real estate agent Kevin Moran, says it is happening every day. They were never really invested. Most of the people who lost the houses didn’t lose any money because they never put any money down.”
“Though their credit is damaged, and they could face legal action in some circumstances, they got to live in a new house for a couple of years, and some of them even managed to get some money with home equity loans or by refinancing.”‘
“Nobody seems to be saying, ‘Look, I made a contract with you. I borrowed money from you. I’m gonna do everything I can to pay off that obligation.’ People just seem to be saying, ‘Look, take the house. Good-bye. I’m leaving,’ Kroft says.”
From The Sun. “It’s almost like having a piece of Orange County under your feet. But no Meadowbrook Park Lofts homeowner opening their front doors will experience that hip, trendy lifestyle once they step outside.”
“Twelve live-work townhomes on Third Street in downtown San Bernardino went on the market a couple weeks ago, boasting two-car garages, balconies, and ground-level space for office or retail use. As of last week, one loft was sold. They range from $350,000 to $360,000.”
“If you’re pondering whether to buy, be prepared to get showered with monetary incentives. ANR Homes and San Bernardino have partnered to offer some pretty hefty draws, like a $100,000 down-payment assistance program for people who already live or work in the city.”
“‘We’re just trying to stimulate some interest in downtown,’ said Lisa Pereira, director of sales and marketing for ANR.”
“The facts are as plain as day: These pristine townhomes are surrounded by a moribund downtown. Adjacent to a jumble of older tract homes, the lofts are located across the street from a couple of old business buildings and Meadowbrook Park.”
“‘The disadvantage to that project, particularly for a senior, is two flights of stairs,’ said Dale Rauch, a contractor who lives in Grand Terrace and took peek at the lofts a week ago.”
“But seniors aren’t the sales target. City leaders hope young professionals - county workers, lawyers, teachers - will move into Meadowbrook.”
“Rauch can’t picture himself living there, at least for now. ‘I think it’s a little ahead of its time,’ Rauch said.”
“His wife works right down the street for the San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools Office. ‘It’d be fantastic for her,’ he said. ‘But … just down around the corner they found two people murdered.’”
“If dreams of transforming downtown San Bernardino come true, getting in on the ground floor could be one of the best real-estate decisions you’ll ever make. The area, though, has a long way to go.”
“Night life is virtually nonexistent unless you count the homeless people hanging out at local parks after the sun sets. Also, 48 registered sex offenders live in the 92408 ZIP code.”