A Riches To Rags Story In California
The Orange County Register reports from California. “Kim Freeman calls her tale a ‘riches to rags story.’ At the center of it is a house in Tustin her husband calls ‘the albatross.’ The good news here is that the Freemans’ house is in escrow after 2 1/2 years on the market. The bad news is they’ve had to cut their price to $563,000 – $226,000 below their original asking price and $140,000 less than what they paid for the three-bedroom ranch house.”
“To make matters worse, the Freemans’ marriage has broken up, in part because of the house. And Kim Freeman…has been laid off from her job.The couple now is six months behind on their mortgage and could lose the home outright if their escrow doesn’t close.”
“After trying for 1 ½ years to sell his Mediterranean-style house beside a bridle path in Nellie Gail, Laguna Hills resident Paul Beyer’s cut his $2.09 million price by $600,000, and still hasn’t had a single written offer.”
“Beyer has decided to try something different. On March 1, he’ll auction off the house in his back yard.”
“‘It’s been just a year of – ugh!’ said Beyer. ‘You ride it down. I wanted to do it right. I kept groping for the right thing. If I had more offers, I could have adjusted. I was in a vacuum.’”
“When Bill and Kim Freeman bought their Charloma Drive house in the spring of 2004. They had just sold a home in Las Flores for a $180,000 profit after owning it for less than a year. Their plan was to do the same with the Tustin home, reselling at a higher price in less than three years.”
“They saw the three-bedroom home on a corner lot, noticed it had a remodeled kitchen and pounced before another buyer could get it. They paid $703,000. In retrospect, she said, they probably moved too fast.”
“‘We were caught up in that house-buying frenzy,’ Freeman said. ‘Back then, you didn’t think you could ever lose.’”
“They put $70,000 down, all that remained from their $180,000 profit from the Las Flores house after taxes and paying off debts. They were able to afford the home by using two interest-only loans. Their house payment was $3,300 a month, but would reset to more than $5,000 after three years, more than they could afford.”
“After a year, they were ready to move out. They put the home up for sale for $789,000 in the spring of 2005. They got an offer for $750,000. Acting on their agent’s advice, they rejected it – a decision the Freemans now regret.”
“In the fall, when sales slowed, the only ones stopping by their open houses were curious neighbors. A couple of buyers offered to pay $700,000, which they considered to be ‘bottom-feeder offers.’ Not now.”
“‘If you had a crystal ball, you’d do a lot of things differently,’ she said.”
“In March 2007, the couple rejected a $675,000 offer because it would have meant losing their down payment, plus an additional $10,000 in cash they’d have to pay at closing. It was their last chance.”
“This past fall, they finally went into escrow, selling the home for $563,000, $70,000 less than what they owe on the mortgages. Because it is a ’short sale,’ they can’t close until the bank agrees to accept less than the full loan amount, so the deal is in limbo.”
“The house now sits empty. The swing set that they bought for their daughters has been abandoned since Freeman has no room for it in her new apartment.”
“‘My husband used to refer to this house as an albatross, and I get it now,’ Freeman said. ‘Everything about this house was bad timing.’”
The North County Times. “Oceanside building chief Jim Zacaro said the city issued 147 building permits for single-family homes in 2007, compared with 298 permits in 2005 and 285 permits in 2006.”
“‘We’re starting to see a real slowdown,’ he said.”
“Zacaro said nowhere is that more evident than in the Arrowood development, a 1,000-home subdivision that has been growing since 2001 on about 600 acres north of Highway 76.”
“In the early days of the project, prospective buyers lined up to buy new homes as soon as they were available. Now - in the roughly five Arrowood neighborhoods still under construction — there are several empty pads and finished houses waiting for buyers.”
“‘They’ve stopped building,’ said John Greenway, who said he bought a home in Arrowood in 2004.”
“Association data shows that in the fourth quarter of 2005 - when the housing market was strong - there were 48 new homes for sale in the city, compared to 94 for sale during the same period in 2007.”
“In 2005, when the quarter ended, 17 of those 48 homes had not sold. In 2007, 75 of the 94 homes had not sold by the end of the quarter.”
The Press Enterprise. “More than a year after The Promenade Shops at Dos Lagos opened along Interstate 15 in Corona, many of the tenants in the upscale shopping center are struggling and even more are complaining that not enough people know the place exists.”
“The 360,000-square-foot lakeside center, designed to resemble a traditional Main Street, has run into the headwinds of a weakening economy and housing crash.”
“‘It was poor planning. They thought they would build this and the people would come and it doesn’t happen,’ said Angela Myers, owner of Bella’s Boutique, one of more than 70 tenants at Dos Lagos, which was created as a ‘lifestyle center.’”
“Myers said her store at Dos Lagos is losing money with no turning point in sight.”
“At Z Gallerie, assistant store manager Kristy Guerrero said the home furnishings store opened with strong sales that diminished dramatically with the drop-off in housing construction. She said the store started with about 32 sales people, then over the summer laid off all but 10.”
“Inland Economist John Husing said the timing of the Dos Lagos center, which was expected to demonstrate the growing household income and sophistication of western Riverside County, ‘has been terrible.’”
“Riverside County’s once booming retail ‘turned on a dime,’ Husing said. Husing said he believes the busted housing market is the major cause for the drop-off in retail sales. He said the Dos Lagos center probably is harmed by exceptionally heavy foreclosures in communities along the Interstate 15 corridor.”
The Sacramento Bee. “In 24 years as CEO of Sacramento’s Safe Credit Union, Henry Wirz said he’s never seen such ‘widespread credit problems in the Sacramento region.’”
“It began last September with rising delinquencies on car loans. By December, the late payments spread to real estate loans. Now, increasingly, borrowers have maxed out their credit cards and home equity lines of credit, said Wirz.”
“And the problems, he said, appear worst in newer neighborhoods.”
“Wirz talked about a credit crisis he believes is still in early stages. Here are excerpts. Q: You’ve been here since 1984 and…this is the worst credit problem you’ve ever seen in Sacramento?”
“A:…’In every crisis, when we first have a downturn, it’s the people at the bottom of the economic pyramid who seem to experience the worst outcomes. I think what surprised us was in this downturn we’re seeing people who had, at the outset, relatively good credit having negative outcomes.’”
“‘In this downturn, where we analyzed the folks having problems, we saw a disproportionate number of people in that 680 to 719 credit score.’”
“Q: You’ve said you saw the problem start in September with auto loan delinquencies. What explains what you’re seeing?”
“A: ‘It makes sense in retrospect. You kind of prioritize your obligations….I think, for a lot of people, the most important thing was to hang onto their house. This is primarily a problem of people having too many bills and not enough income to cover them. So they began juggling their bills. Credit cards, auto loans, things like that took second place to keeping the mortgage payment up.’”
“‘We’ve seen a lot of the credit cards and home equity lines get fully utilized as people have drawn them down to support their monthly expenses.’”
“‘I think we’re now at the end of that rope. There just isn’t any more credit card balance available. There isn’t any home equity available, and now people are having to confront the ultimate problem, which is how do I keep my house? How do I keep my mortgage intact? I think that’s why we’re seeing people coming in.’”
“Q: You say we’re at the front end of this credit crisis? How long might this continue? A: ‘In almost every kind of lending problem it takes 18 to 24 months to work through it. I hope this one is a problem we can work through that quick. I’ve heard some others say it might not be.’”
“Q: Earlier you said that homebuyers are bypassing sellers altogether and waiting for a bank to take back the home. They think that’s where the better deal is. When do you see this housing market starting to stabilize?”
“A: ‘We’ll know there’s a turnaround when we see buyers come in and buy these properties earlier in the process. Right now, were not seeing that. People are waiting for the bottom. Everybody wants to buy at the bottom, and there cannot be a bottom until buyers come in. We’re not there yet. My guess is we’re maybe into April, maybe June or July, before we see that.’”
The Merced Sun Star. “Merced’s housing market ended 2007 on a down note, with prices and sales in December continuing the slide that defined the year. The county’s median home price fell to $257,000 in December, a 21.2 percent dip from December 2006, according to DataQuick.”
“Sales activity posted an even sharper dropoff, with just 150 houses trading hands, compared with 347 homes sold in December 2006 (although the data did not include the last day of the month).”
“Dorothy Kielty, president of the Merced County Association of Realtors, said plummeting prices could be traced mainly to foreclosures and ’short sales.’”
“Sellers should do their research…said Realtor Peggy Flanagan, but the question for them is how badly they need to unload their house.”
“‘At this point in time they have to make some real hard decisions,’ said Flanagan. ‘The guy that’s starting a new job and has to leave the area is a whole lot different than the guy who’s just wondering what kind of price he can get for his home. We’re actually counseling people that if they don’t have to sell, then don’t.’”
“With Merced’s prices dropping closer to the $200,000 mark, Flanagan said she’s seeing the return of out-of-town investors, a trend she called a positive sign.”
“‘To me, that’s really the tail-that-wags-the-dog indicator,’ said Flanagan. ‘We’re getting looked at again (by out-of-town agents and investors), and by 2010 people will be wishing that they bought in 2008.’”