Many Sellers Are Having Trouble Facing The Facts
The San Francisco Chronicle reports from California. “The developer of the recently opened Eight Orchids condominium mid-rise in Oakland hopes to auction off nearly a third of the units, with some starting bids $300,000 below prior asking prices, as builders struggle to unload new properties in the current housing climate. ‘It tells you it’s a very weak market and the normal selling process is not going well,’ said Ken Rosen, chairman of the Fisher Center for Real Estate and Urban Economics at UC Berkeley.”
“A complicating factor in Oakland is the number of large condo developments near downtown that have opened or begun selling the past year. Oakland condo developers are only selling a few units per month on average, said Alan Mark, president of the Mark Co.”
“In January, median resale condo prices in Alameda County stood at $360,000, down 19 percent from a year earlier, according to DataQuick. Sales fell 47 percent. The firm doesn’t track new condo sales specifically.”
“The heavily discounted starting bids and auction process itself should reassure people they’re paying the fair market value, said Stuart Gruendl, CEO of BayRock. ‘I have a big pool of buyers, they’re more than tire kickers and now, I’m going to create an event to create some urgency,’ Gruendl said.”
“He added that he isn’t ‘desperate’ to sell or under pressure from his lenders but acknowledged that the market is challenging.”
“The minimum bid for one-bedrooms is $245,000, down from as high as $520,888; two-bedrooms will start at $325,000, down from as high as $630,888; and three-bedrooms will begin at $475,000, discounted from as much as $805,888.”
“There is no ’secret reserve,’ meaning any unit that receives at least the minimum offer will go to the bidder.”
The LA Times. “As the housing slump worsened last fall, Don Dale struggled to find buyers for the $900,000 houses he was selling for Shea Homes in the hills of Aliso Viejo. Then in January, Shea slashed prices to about $750,000. Dale sold nine in one day.”
“‘If there is value, there are buyers,’ Dale said.”
“Stuck with excess inventory, builders throughout California are beginning to offer steep discounts on new homes, sometimes at a loss. Centex Corp. is touting the ‘greatest prices in years’ in its ads. In San Bernardino County, builder Van Daele Homes is advertising 35% discounts.”
“‘Builders don’t have the luxury of waiting another year for the market to turn — they need the cash flow now,’ said Patrick S. Duffy, principal of a consultant to home builders. ‘It’s better for them to take 90 cents on the dollar today than to risk no cash flow at all because they’re not selling any houses.’”
“Carlos Vega spent an afternoon last week driving to sales offices for newly built subdivisions in the hills of Rancho Cucamonga, where five builders have projects. Vega said he had made several offers but hadn’t yet committed to anything because the rival builders keep topping one another’s deals.”
“One builder, he said, offered to sell him a model home, complete with landscaping and designer furnishings, at a price Vega estimated was about 20% below what the property would have fetched a few months ago.”
“‘They’re throwing me offers left and right,’ said Vega.”
“In Victorville, new houses built by KB Home are selling for about 33% less than they did two years ago because of the combination of price cuts and size reductions, CEO Jeffrey Mezger said at a conference last week.”
“In the Riverside County suburb of Lake Elsinore last week, a saleswoman at one housing development that had cut prices recalled getting a visit from a field representative from a rival firm that had kept prices level.”
“The saleswoman, who declined to give her name because she was not authorized to speak for the company, said her counterpart asked for a price list. The reason: The rival hoped to persuade her corporate headquarters to make similar trims.”
“If there is any grumbling about price cuts, it’s from people selling their own homes. In Lake Elsinore, for instance, more than 100 resale homes are listed in the $300,000-to-$400,000 range. For that price, buyers can get a brand-new model that has been freshly discounted.”
“Jack Lloyd has been trying to sell his Palmdale house for nearly a year. He’s cut the asking price several times, and he’s now seeking $285,000 — down from the original $425,000.”
“But Lloyd isn’t hopeful, noting that new houses in nearby developments are $240,000. ‘Who’s going to buy mine?’ he asked. ‘Sure, you have to put in carpet, put in the lawn in those, but is that going to cost you 40 grand? I don’t think so.’”
“‘Many of the home sellers are having trouble facing the facts,’ said Lancaster real estate agent James Baker. ‘The best prices are not on the privately owned houses, they’re from the builders and the banks.’”
The Contra Costa Times. “Ruby Aldana-Bonite said she believes the new agreement by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to only buy mortgages with independent appraisals could help ‘keep everybody’s noses clean.’”
“‘A lot of times, orders would be dangled in front of you, ‘If you come in at this value, we have more work for you,’ she said. ‘It’s not right.’”
“Aldana-Bonite, of Benicia-based Aldana-Bonite Appraisals, said that although she favored the new rule, there would be few changes for independent real estate appraisers.”
“‘Banks have already gotten rid of in-house appraisers now and are now using a third party,’ she said. ‘And that’s good if they’re not getting that pressure from the loan officer and you’re not pressured or leaned toward a certain value.’”
“Rob Denton, owner of Denton Valuation in Walnut Creek, said that ‘appraisal shopping,’ or when mortgage brokers and loan agents called multiple appraisers to find one who agreed to their price, was common in the housing boom.”
“‘The feds are suggesting that when you are prompted by a broker to reach a certain value, those people should be reported,’ he said. ‘But there doesn’t seem to be any clearinghouse for doing that. … We’re not going to accept work under those premises, but there are no avenues for corrections.’”
The Press Enterprise. “In a move to help people buy homes and refinance out of unaffordable mortgages, the Federal Housing Administration today will raise the limits for one year on FHA-insured mortgages.”
“Housing and mortgage experts said that while the new availability of FHA mortgages will not cure the housing crisis, it is a step in the right direction. It will not, however, help a homeowners who owe more than their houses are worth.”
“John Marcell, a California Association of Mortgage Brokers official who lobbied to have the FHA ceiling raised, said the Inland median price reflects an effort to minimize the impact of a burst of distress home sales by homeowners unable to afford their mortgages and by lenders. These sellers have been willing to accept ‘fire sale’ prices, he said.”
“Will Herring, government affairs chairman for the Inland Empire chapter of California Association of Mortgage Brokers, cautioned that the new ceiling will not help the many families who owe more money on their house than it is worth and will not be able to refinance with FHA, Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac.”
“‘Everyone who wants to refinance cannot refinance because they are upside down,’ he said.”
“‘Every little bit helps, but it is not going to clear up the issues overhanging the housing and mortgage markets,’ said Greg McBride, senior financial analyst at Bankrate.com.”
“McBride said one obstacle is that houses are still too expensive for many first-time buyers. And refinancing is not an option for people who don’t earn enough to stay in their homes, he said, adding, ‘… The only way they can afford the payments is if you made the payments for them.’”
The Voice of San Diego. “Karen Turk was laid off from her job at an escrow company in July. And before her second pink slip came in October from the escrow company she moved to. And before December, when she was laid off again from a third escrow company.”
“Turk’s not alone. A 20-year veteran of the escrow business, she guesses 98 percent of the people she’s worked with have been laid off and thrust into a burgeoning pool of job-seekers. Every month, San Diego loses more high-paying jobs, especially those tied to real estate.”
“‘I can count the ones who are left on one hand,’ Turk said of her friends in the real estate industry. ‘This is all they’ve ever done. You’re thinking, ‘What do I do now? How do I recreate myself?’”
“‘Some of the people who are losing their jobs, they might be segueing into those other jobs,’ said Gary Moss, labor market information specialist for the San Diego Workforce Partnership. ‘But as a viable option, with a comparable salary, it’ll be a stretch for most people.’”
“Thousands of out-of-work San Diegans need help now. Middle-aged, single-career workers like Turk need considerable training to even think about making the kind of money they were making before. She said managers like her were making between $70,000 and $100,000.”
“‘I’ve already resigned myself that if I make half of the $75,000 I’ll be happy,’ she said. ‘For someone in your 50s, in your early 50s, it’s readjusting your entire lifestyle.’”
“Turk is learning computer skills and hopes to begin night classes to become a medical assistant. Even the way she knows how to look for jobs — the newspaper — has changed since the last time she went job-hunting, decades ago, she said.”
“‘If they’re not buying homes, people still get sick, they get colds and chicken pox,’ she said. ‘I wonder, will I go back in the housing market again? I don’t want to do this again.’”
“Alan Gin, economist at the University of San Diego, said he’s ratcheting down his optimism from earlier months, but still holds the region won’t experience a technical recession with negative job growth.”
“With local universities churning out thousands of degreed professionals every year, Gin theorized some San Diegans have taken a job with less pay to live here. It’s like Tony Gwynn sticking with the Padres, he said.”
“‘It’s the San Diego discount,’ he said. ‘In a pure sense, as an economist, you think, ‘Well, if it’s making people happy then it’s OK.’ But you have this problem where people might be happy, but they’d be happier if they were paid better.’”