We Have Never Had This Situation Before In California
The Record Searchlight reports from California. “Here’s another sign of a stagnant real estate market: Some developers in town are taking their homes off the market and turning them into rentals. Two weeks ago, East Oak Estates in south Redding announced this would be the last weekend some of its homes would be for sale. They were going to start leasing them out.”
“But East Oak developer Karen Margrave said buyers waiting for some colossal closeout sale will be sorely disappointed. She has no plans to sell her homes at below what she paid, nor she says will other builders. So they’re getting into the rental business while waiting it out.”
“Some homes in East Oak Estates already have been reduced as much as $57,000.”
“‘We have sold homes recently, though it’s much slower than we’d like to see. We know prices are going to go back up, and we believe they will start rising again next spring,’ Margrave said in an e-mail.”
“Margrave added that other builders like Palomar Builders Inc. already have moved their inventory into rentals and will hold them until the market turns.”
“Brad Garbutt, who’s been selling real estate in Shasta County for years, said it’s unusual for developers to rent back their homes. ‘I don’t recall any developer on a large scale doing something like that,’ Garbutt of Real Estate Professionals GMAC said. ‘Developers usually can’t do that. They can’t stop everything because the bills keep coming.’”
“Glen Jones of Greater Shasta Homeplaces in Redding agreed that it’s strange to see a builder get into the rental business. ‘I have never seen it before, but we have never had this situation,’ Jones said.”
The San Fernando Valley Business Journal. “Oh what a difference a year makes. One year ago, housing sales were booming. One year later, sales are at their worst in 16 years. Depending on who you talk to, borrowers, Wall Street, banks and the Federal Reserve receive their share of blame.”
“Yet mortgage brokers are the group getting the largest portion of bad press. Many brokers are fighting back, blaming the banks and mortgage companies that package the loans and establish broker fees.”
“‘The bottom line is that banks definitely allowed people to over-leverage themselves, and now they are in a period where they have to correct the market,’ said Bill Knox, senior loan officer at Bristol Home Loans in Sherman Oaks.”
“Knox, whose sales have been 40 percent in subprime loans, said the majority of lenders are conscientious about explaining convoluted loans to clients – even though loan documents average, he said, between 15 and 100 pages.”
“‘You go over the main information,’ Knox said. ‘You try to explain it to them until you are blue in the face.’”
“One of Knox’s clients read a mortgage contract all day, he said. ‘The next day she came in and signed everything. And then a year later, she calls to say she didn’t understand any of it.’”
The Mercury News. “Increasingly, as homeowners fall behind on their loan payments or lack enough equity in their homes to sell them for more than their mortgage balances, they are contacting their mortgage lenders for possible help.”
“In the beginning, his calls were transferred repeatedly and often dropped, he said. With persistence, he reached the lenders’ correct departments and told his story. He and his wife, Grace, were both diagnosed with cancer at different times in the past four years. Both had to quit working during their treatments.”
“‘I believed what they said about calling your bank ahead of time, because they don’t want your house,’ said Chavez, who first called his lenders for help in August. ‘I didn’t get that response at all. They told me they had no programs to deal with that type of thing.’”
“In response to a call Wednesday by NACA for a boycott of Countrywide because, according to the group, the company ‘refuses to restructure loans to what homeowners can afford,’ the lender issued a statement Thursday.”
“Chavez now is back at work in quality control for a tea manufacturer, following about eight months of treatment for lymphoma. His wife was treated for sarcoma for a year and went back to work as a teacher in 2005.”
“Their household income is about $90,000. But they’ve nearly maxed out their $120,000 home equity line of credit, and because they can only afford the minimum payment option on their adjustable-rate loan, the principle balance on their first mortgage is growing rather than shrinking with every payment they make.”
“‘They were nice about it,’ Chavez said of the representatives he eventually spoke with at his lenders. ‘But I mean, it’s still, ‘They don’t have a program for you.’”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “Of the Bay Area’s 236 ZIP codes, 25 are foreclosure hot spots - places where more than eight of every 1,000 homes were repossessed by lenders this year.”
“Even in expensive areas like Marin County the crisis is beginning to be felt. One of the Bay Area’s highest-priced ZIP codes, 94920, in the tony Belvedere/Tiburon area, was home to nine foreclosures - including a $1.3 million ‘Bel-Aire tract home’ with ‘floor-to-ceiling windows … and French doors leading to the pool.’”
“In the Antioch ZIP code of 94531, the median price stood at $452,000 in July and August, according to DataQuick. But that seems to be dropping fast, putting more homeowners in danger of losing their largest asset.”
“Real estate agent Luis Salas has about 10 listings in the Antioch area; eight are short sales, in which the sellers ask the bank to take the properties for less than they owe on the mortgage.”
“In part, Salas and others blame the steep competition for buyers’ attention. Along the line separating Antioch and Brentwood sit winding streets filled with just-finished homes - more than 40 percent of the housing stock there is considered new, according to the Construction Industry Research Board.”
“With so many choices for buyers, builders are offering big price reductions or luxurious upgrades. Why buy a home from a bank or distressed homeowner when a builder will kick in granite countertops or knock off tens of thousands of dollars from the sale price?”
“‘They can afford to give you $100,000 in incentives,’ Salas said. ‘I can’t afford to give you $10,000 in closing costs.’”
“Towns closer to the region’s urban core - Richmond, Oakland and East Palo Alto - also show rising foreclosure rates…Those areas do share some of the other characteristics of the most foreclosure-prone parts of Antioch or Oakley: affordability and large price drops.”
“For the first time since the mid-1990s, some Bay Area counties are reducing property taxes for significant numbers of homeowners, mainly those who bought houses since late 2005 in areas where prices have declined.”
“Most of the reductions were in cities where a lot of subdivisions have been built in the past three years, such as Antioch, Pittsburg, Brentwood, Oakley and San Ramon, says Contra Costa County Assessor Gus Kramer.”
“This is the first time since 1995 that his office has proactively reduced property values.”
“Santa Clara County automatically reduced taxes on about 18,000 properties, compared with 6,000 last year. Most of the reductions were on mid- and lower-price homes and condos in cities with less-than-stellar school districts, says Santa Clara County Assessor Larry Stone.”
“San Francisco Assessor Phil Ting says, ‘At this time we haven’t seen any more (property tax) reductions than normal … but I think it’s coming.’”
The Street.com. “Gary Feldstein from Ojai, Calif., has hired auctioneer Sheldon Good & Co. to dispose of the house he bought for about $1.25 million three years ago. His hoped-for take from a sealed-bid auction set for Nov. 7, at least $4 million, says Jamie Somers, the broker in Ojai who sold Feldstein the house but who won’t be getting the listing this time.”
“Somers says he is ’skeptical’ about how well Feldstein’s sale will go, although he says he understands the seller’s need for speed. ‘Even in the upper end, things are not selling quickly,’ he explains. And although Somers acknowledges that Feldstein ‘did quite a number’ in renovating and furnishing the house, ‘he’s asking quite a premium. The upper end is good, but I don’t know if it’s as good as he thinks it is.’ (The lower end, he says, ‘is horrible.’)”
“‘The market is going to determine what the house is worth,’ says Feldstein.”
“Says Feldstein about what’s really underlying his auction decision: ‘I’m a New Yorker,’ he declares. From a timing standpoint, ‘today is okay, but yesterday is always better.’”
The Orange County Register. “Mission Viejo broker/economist Gary Watts, whose home-price insights are widely watching in the local real estate community, conceded Friday that his 2007 housing forecast was wrong, but in his 2008 forecast remains upbeat, predicting that home sales will bounce back.”
“‘The numbers for September and October may be our darkest hour, and then things are going to improve,’ Watts said.”
“Watts didn’t issue a price forecast, saying there’s too much uncertainty…A year ago, Watts forecast a 7% gain in home prices this year. House prices actually were flat through August, and are down 2.2% in the latest weekly figures from DataQuick.”
“Watts said he expected inventory to decline this year (plus) higher summer sales and for the Federal Reserve to lower interest rates earlier in the year. And he hadn’t foreseen the subprime mortgage meltdown.”
“His published forecast notes: …In the 1990s, real estate values dropped over 19% in Orange County; in this housing downturn it has been minimal. So what makes this cycle different. The truth lies in the fact that today’s homeowners have more income, more equity and more wealth than in previous cycles.”
The Press Telegram. “The California Association of Realtors annual Expo 2007 ran from Tuesday through Thursday at the Anaheim Convention Center.”
“The housing forecast, delivered on Wednesday by CAR Chief Economist Leslie Appleton-Young was perhaps the low point of the conference. The state’s median home price will incur the biggest drop in 15 years, as sales slide to their lowest point in more than 20 years, Appleton-Young said.”
“The forecast called for California’s median home price to fall 4 percent to $553,000 in 2008, while sales will fall 9 percent to 334,500 units. The last time sales fell below 2008’s forecast of 334,500 units was in 1985, when the volume reached 328,270 units, according to CAR.”
“Appleton-Young blamed the anticipated price drop on a market weighed down by sluggish sales, the mortgage crisis and because the market is no longer boosted by consumer expectations of rising home prices.”
“‘We really are going through a major adjustment right now to a market that isn’t fueled by those expectations,’ Appleton-Young said.”