Everyone’s Waiting For Prices To Drop Further In California
The San Francisco Chronicle reports from California. “The dead lawns and for-sale signs are stark evidence of the Bay Area’s foreclosure crisis, and Antioch’s Meadow Creek Estates is at the epicenter of it. With 271 homes, or more than 2 percent of all residences, already foreclosed upon in the first eight months of this year, the 94531 ZIP code has the Bay Area’s highest foreclosure rate, according to a Chronicle analysis.”
“The foreclosure rate here is seven times that of the region as a whole and nearly 1,000 percent higher than it was a year ago. This small area of Antioch, with 23 foreclosures for every 1,000 homes, has twice the bank repossession rate of greater Stockton, an area often cited as the No. 1 foreclosure spot in California.”
“Burgeoning growth caused prices to rise rapidly. Houses on Catanzaro sold for about $150,000 when they were new in 1994. Two years ago, they went for more than $500,000.”
“Now prices have fallen precipitously. Catanzaro homes today are selling in the low $400,000s, if they sell at all.”
“Trinette Nastor of Fairfield owned two of the Catanzaro foreclosures. She said she bought the three-bedroom homes, located across the street from each other, for $530,000 each in late 2005, as an investment in a partnership with two acquaintances. She thinks the acquaintances got her into the deal because she owns her own business in Vacaville, so she had the credit to qualify for mortgages.”
“‘The plan was we were going to fix them up a little bit, flip them and then go from there,’ she said. Instead, ‘As soon as the market went for a loop, they were worth $470,000.’”
“Nastor said she made a couple of monthly payments of about $3,000 each, but then couldn’t keep up. ‘I kept getting paperwork (from the banks),’ she said. ‘I was like, ‘Look, we’ve got to do something about this.’ That’s when her partners disappeared, she said.”
“‘I went crazy, I didn’t know what to do,’ she said. ‘I had to let (the houses) go because they would bring my business and my health down.’”
“She stopped making payments and the lenders foreclosed on both homes in January.”
The Orange County Register. “A recovery in the housing market may start taking hold sometime in the coming two to three years, depending on whom you asked at the California Association of Realtors convention that ended Saturday.”
“Richard Green, the Oliver T. Carr Jr. Chair of Real Estate & Finance at George Washington University, cautioned real estate agents that they may need to wait longer. ‘Just try to hang on for three years,’ he said.”
“‘Realtors like good news,’ Green said. ‘For the short run, I don’t have a lot.’”
“‘It’s going to get better, but very slowly,’ said Maria Natalia Lopez, an agent in Wilmington. ‘Everyone’s waiting for prices to drop further.’”
“Easy financing, resulting in a runup in home prices, started the slump, Green said, and as a result, home sales are almost half the level of two years ago. Six of the 10 metro areas with the nation’s highest default rates are in California.”
“‘There are no economic models,’ he said. ‘We’ve never seen anything exactly like this before.’”
“Dave Emerson, an agent in Los Alamitos, said he feels like he’s on the shore watching a ‘tsunami of foreclosures’ coming. ‘I’m just scared to death,’ Emerson said. ‘Maybe I’m a victim of the media.’”
The Union Tribune. “In recent weeks, the mortgage industry has put out the word that it is shocked, simply shocked at the amount of fraud involved in home loans. ‘People are deceiving lenders at an alarming rate,’ said Jonathan Kempner, who heads the Mortgage Bankers Association.”
“But how innocent is the mortgage industry? Were lenders, as Kempner said, ‘the principal victims of mortgage fraud’? Or did the industry, with its lax standards, create an atmosphere in which fraud became pervasive? And did some mortgage firms aid and abet the fraud?”
“Bob Simpson, whose company investigates mortgage insurance claims, said he has found that many mortgage brokers encouraged borrowers to overstate their income to qualify for high-priced mortgages.”
“Simpson tells of how a manicurist gained a jumbo mortgage using a loan application that said she was making $90,000 per year. An exterminator gained a loan by saying he made $132,000. A rental car worker was listed as making $144,000.”
“Simpson can’t believe the mortgage firms were unaware of what was going on. ‘How can you look at a loan application saying that some part-time manicurist working out of her home is making $7,500 a month without being a little suspicious?’ he asked.”
“Mark Miller, a bankruptcy attorney in San Diego, said that in one bankruptcy case he’s handling, the borrowers never saw any of the actual loan documents for their home and were not present when the documents were stamped by a notary public.”
“‘The mortgage guy told them, ‘Don’t worry. I’ve got a notary I deal with,’ who happened to be a relative,’ Miller said.”
“The borrowers thought they were signing up for a fixed-rate loan at 7 percent interest. Instead they got an adjustable-rate loan that has since ballooned to 14 percent, driving them into bankruptcy.”
The Bakersfield Californian. “As Friday approached, Otto Chacon was scrambling for a solution. The first-time homebuyer was nervously anticipating Oct. 12, the day when the interest rate on his home loan was scheduled to rise, bumping his monthly payments from $2,200 a month to nearly $3,000.”
“Chacon, an electrical construction worker, knows his family will be unable to afford the new payment. He repeatedly called his out-of-state lender, NovaStar, but says he never heard back. He tried to refinance with two other mortgage companies, but cannot pay thousands in upfront fees.”
“‘It’s all a mess,’ Chacon said. ‘I wanted to move into a house and I guess I went for it.’”
“As of June, an estimated 42,560 subprime loans, the majority of which are adjustable, were active in Kern County, according to First American LoanPerformance,. Those loans accounted for 27 percent of all Kern mortgages, according to LoanPerformance.”
“Housing experts are bracing for the first quarter of 2008, when many adjustable rate mortgages will reset for the first time, said Richard Castro, a spokesman for the Anaheim office of a national housing nonprofit.”
“‘The state is going to be at the epicenter of the foreclosure crisis in 2008,’ Castro said.”
“In September, one in 3.8 home sale listings were for ‘distressed’ properties, the majority bank repossessions or short sales where a lender forgives a portion of the loan to avoid foreclosure, according to a report by Bakersfield appraiser Gary Crabtree.”
“Those distressed homes are selling for 10.7 percent less than regular listings, putting downward pressure on prices, the report states.”
“Chacon moved his family from Los Angeles to Bakersfield in 2004, lured by the city’s relatively affordable homes. With poor credit, an adjustable rate mortgage seemed like his only chance to become an owner. Chacon and his wife, Rosa, took the plunge and bought their first home for $292,000 in a northeast Bakersfield neighborhood.”
“They like it here and want to stay. But the looming monthly payment increase is weighing heavily on Chacon. ‘I know you’re responsible for your finances, but the way they picture it is, in two years you can refinance and you’ll be OK,’ he said.”
The Mercury News. “Though the prospect of seeing a house similar to the one she and her fiance bought just 10 months ago sell for $180,000 less than they paid made Cindy Jorgensen ‘want to puke,’ her American dream-turned-nightmare had somewhat of a happy ending.”
“Her mother Shannon purchased a four-bedroom, two-bathroom property, the next-to-last one in Saturday’s 34-home auction, in the same Manteca subdivision for $107,000 below the asking price.”
“‘At least we were able to get something good out of it,’ Cindy Jorgensen said. ‘It will be good to have a babysitter close by.’”
“Also in the Pleasanton Hilton ballroom were some of the existing 26 homeowners, curious to see how much of a financial nightmare would be caused by brand-new properties similar to theirs selling for hundreds of thousands of dollars less.”
“‘Words really can’t describe how I feel right now, these results justify our worst fears,’ Paseo West resident Dave Cantrell said.”
“Cantrell, who has become the organizer in the homeowner’s attempt to get some sort of rebate from Anderson Homes, said he lost $270,000 due to the disparity between his home and a similar one that sold Saturday.”
“‘There’s a false bottom that’s being generated by these fire sales, and it’s going to take years for us to recover,’ he said.”
“‘My impression is that they were mostly families,’ said Craig Barton, chief financial officer of Anderson Homes.”
“Cantrell agreed, saying: ‘That may be the only good news that came out of this. I’m looking forward to having good neighbors, just not at a quarter of a million dollars less.’”
“Overall, the homes went for about 32 percent below the original asking price. The minimum bids had been set about 40 percent below asking price.”
“For Cindy Jorgensen, who moved from a condominium in Dublin that she’s still trying to sell, the worry is about what impact Saturday’s auction might have when applying for future home loans. ‘Will we get the price we paid for it, or will we get the bottomed-out price,’ she said. ‘It’s just been frustrating.’”