An Apology Of Sorts In California
The Orange County Register reports from California. “Back when the state’s housing future was a legitimate debate, maybe two or three years ago, imagine if I had quoted some expert predicting that pricing would hit the ugliness of the mid-1990s while selling a house would be as difficult as it had been in nearly a quarter century. Folks close to the industry would scream, ‘Who is this doom-and-gloom quack?’”
“Well, in my hands I have just a projection. And the author is no less than the California Association of Realtors.”
“‘Buyers will have a wait-and-see attitude for some time,’ says CAR deputy economist Robert Kleinhenz.”
“California Association of Realtor chief economist Leslie Appleton-Young had a confession to make at the annual forecast lunch, or as she put it ‘an apology of sorts.’”
“Two years ago, amid a red-hot market, her forecast dismissed fears of a bursting California real estate bubble and called for only modest sales declines.”
“Two years later, the state’s seen a dramatic sales drop. In August 2005, the cyclical peak, sales ran at an annualized rate of 650,000 homes. By year end 2007, Appleton-Young foresees the sales rate under 300,000.”
“‘We’ve had a fundamental change in the mindset of the buyer,’ she says. ‘There is no reason (for a buyer) to act.’”
“‘This was more fun three years ago,’ Appleton-Young told the group as her forecast ended. ‘But we need to deal with reality.’”
The Union Tribune. “The 12,000 CAR delegates heard that the median price for existing single-family homes statewide will drop from an estimated $576,000 this year to $553,000 next year.”
“Still, the association said a drop in volume of 9 percent in existing single-family homes would be an improvement over this year’s projected drop of 23 percent.”
“‘It’s a moderation in the pace of decline, so from that perspective I guess it is positive, but we’re certainly getting to a relatively low level of sales,’ said Appleton-Young.”
The Daily News. “CAR President Colleen Badagliacco said tighter credit standards, affordability concerns and ‘a continued standoff between buyers and sellers’ will contribute to continued weakness in the market moving into next year.”
“James Joseph, owner of Century 21 Ambassador and Coldwell Banker Ambassador in Whittier and Century 21 Ambassador in Brea, said the predicted 4 percent drop in California’s median home price is not what he’s seeing.”
“‘Many of the homes I’m seeing now are selling for 15 to 30 percent less than before,’ he said.”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “‘2008 is going to be a rocky road,’ said Robert Kleinhenz, an economist for the trade group. He noted that the dismal sales projection ‘is one of the weakest numbers we’ve seen in a long time. It’s not clear we’re out of the woods where the credit crunch is concerned. We saw a slight impact in our August sales figures, but we’re seeing September sales with a much more dramatic impact.’”
“‘This is the weirdest downturn in the history of California,’ said GU Krueger, vice president at Irvine’s IHP Capital Partners, one of the largest U.S. investors in residential development. ‘Most previous downturns were driven by super-high interest rates or very weak economic fundamentals. This one is neither. It’s driven by prices getting ahead of incomes and by the drying up of financing that was making the run-up in pricing possible.’”
“Most economists agree a turnaround won’t come until the excess inventory of new homes is burned off, foreclosure sales peter out and prices decline to a level enticing to buyers.”
“‘It’s what happens the morning after the party is over,’ Krueger said. ‘We were overvalued, and now we’re depreciating - it will help with affordability, there’s no doubt about that.’”
The Press Democrat. “Stephen Levy, senior economist at the Center for Continuing Study of the California Economy, had a less optimistic outlook. He expects prices to drop between 10 percent and 15 percent overall and perhaps more in some markets.”
“The association forecast ‘conveys the wrong image to people about what’s going to happen in prices in their neighborhood from now on,’ Levy said. ‘It’s going to be more severe. I think that’s good. I think it’s better for us if we get through the correction faster,’ he said.”
“The problem in areas including Sonoma County is an oversupply of homes for sale. Prices have not come down enough to make homes much more affordable for many buyers, and tighter lending requirements present another hurdle.”
“‘Lenders are anticipating that property values will keep falling. So they’re adjusting their loan limits, their risk,’ said Kris Anderson, senior loan consultant for Allstate Mortgage Company in Santa Rosa.”
The Ventura County Star. “Jack Kyser, chief economist of the Los Angeles Economic Development Corp., thinks CAR’s projected median price is optimistic.”
“‘The housing market is going to remain in a mess for awhile,’ he said. ‘The housing market is definitely going through a painful recession that probably won’t go away until 2009.’”
“In September, there were 489 foreclosure filings in Ventura County, up 189 percent from 169 filings for the same month a year ago, RealtyTrac reported.”
“Robert Kleinhenz, a deputy chief economist at CAR, expects to see foreclosure activity climb to a record next year, when mortgage resets on subprime loans peak. ‘We expect in the next few months, we’re going to bear the brunt of the credit crunch,’ Kleinhenz said.”
The Mercury News. “Economist Stephen Levy said ‘we are now at the very beginning’ of a trend in which homeowners who can no longer afford the payments on their adjustable loans have to sell their homes or face foreclosure.”
“‘We’re going to have much more substantial price declines in selected markets,’ he said, ‘and that’s good because when prices fall we will find out there is an underlying demand’ for housing and new construction.”
“‘We need housing, to be attractive for jobs. And the prices simply got out of hand,’ Levy said.”
From CBS News. “In California, where developers have been racing to turn farmers’ fields into subdivisions, they’re now walking away, leaving houses partially built.”
“Those who have already moved in (are) wondering what will hit next.”
“‘I’m concerned that once the weather starts getting bad, there’s tile piled on the roof that could just fly off,’ homeowner Marius Gieske told CBS News correspondent John Blackstone.”
“Dunmore Homes had building projects in a dozen California communities from Bakersfield to Yuba City. Now it’s halted work everywhere, giving up on a fast-falling market.”
“‘We couldn’t sell a moving target,’ said John Slaughter, VP of construction and operations for Dunsmoor Homes. ‘What we wanted to do is stop.’”
“So developers are scrambling to get rid of houses they can’t sell. Many are turning to auctions. As Anderson Homes searches for the bottom, those who bought from the developer at the top feel betrayed.”
“Sherry and Percy Berquist, who paid $597,000 last year were shocked to see $335,000 set as the opening bid for an identical house to be auctioned. The developer may be able to absorb that loss. The Berquists can’t. ‘It’s gonna be very tough,’ said Sherry Berquist.”
“Across the street Amy Sturdevant paid $585,000 for a house. But now the developer has set $295,000 as the opening bid for similar houses down the street.”
“‘I feel like my parents’ grave has been robbed. This was an inheritance. I sit out here and I look at this…’ said Sturdevant.”
“Those like Sturdevant and the Berquists who bought at the peak may be the biggest victims of this housing bust said Financial Planner Patrick McGilvray.”
“‘That’s the real tragedy for the people who got in at the height of the market. They are going to tough it out,’ McGilvray said. ‘They are the ones who are going to carry the water so to speak for this debacle.’”
“If part of the reason for falling prices is overbuilding, it may not be over yet. While construction has slowed builders are still putting up new homes at a rate of more than one million this year.”
From ABC 30.com. “More than two dozen new valley homes will hit the auction block this weekend and some are not happy about it.”
“The slumping housing market has led the builder of a new Merced County subdivision to try a technique usually associated with foreclosed homes. The company is auctioning off more than a third of its available properties.”
“25 new homes in this Los Banos subdivision will be up for auction on Sunday. Low sales have led Anderson Homes to auction off 25 homes in this subdivision and another 34 in Manteca. The builder says the starting minimum bid of $215,000 for the Los Banos properties is about 40% off the retail price.”
“Some homeowners in this subdivision are worried about the impact it will have on their own property values. Maximo Aguilar Junior says he’s upset because he bought his home from the same builder two years ago for about $456,000.”
“‘Of course, we’re concerned about the price, we’re thinking it’s going to drop the price a lot,’ says Aguilar.”
“But Anderson Homes Chief Financial Officer says the auction could actually help get this subdivision back on track. ‘The auction doesn’t set the values, buyers do today so the auction will help us determine that, it will help us reduce the supply, so we feel in the long run that’s a good thing,’ says Craig Barton.”
“Michelle Ritchey and her family live just a few blocks away from the Teal Landing Neighborhood in Los Banos. But they’re hoping to trade up and cash in when many of these homes hit the auction block in San Jose this weekend.”
“‘Our home, we just had it appraised, and it was $259,900 so we said, well, these are starting off at $215,000, we could use a little less and for more room,’ says Ritchey.”