A Well-Traveled Path In California
The New York Times reports on California. “The north end of Clarks Fork Circle in Stockton tells you all you need to know about the depth of the mortgage worries here. On a curve in a handsome new residential development, four of five homes are for sale, at least two of which have already been repossessed by a lender.”
“Once considered a safe alternative to the overheated Bay Area real estate market, Stockton and its streets are now filled with ‘For Sale’ signs and evidence of foreclosures. ‘It is disturbing, there’s no question about it,’ said Mayor Edward J. Chavez, who himself has two houses on the market, with no sales in sight. ‘What was once a vibrant market has kind of hit a brick wall.’”
“Average single-family houses here can still be had for $350,000. But many of the recent house deals, brokers and local officials say, were financed by subprime loans, some of which offered 100 percent financing for a small down payment, occasionally even no money down.”
“‘It’s gone from the most liberal financing I’ve ever seen a few years ago to the most foreclosures and delinquencies I’ve ever seen now,’ said Art Godi, a longtime Stockton real estate agent and the former president of the National Association of Realtors.”
“Alma Neri…bought a modest house in Stockton in 2002 for $223,000. Three years later, Ms. Neri and her husband found an even better house around the corner. The plan was to sell the old house to pay off its mortgage.”
“But now, both of the Neris’ houses are languishing on the market, and the debt from two mortgages, and an equity loan they took to remodel the new house, is piling up.” “‘We made bad decisions,’ said Ms. Neri. ‘We’re worried if we don’t sell by the end of the year, we will lose one of them. We just didn’t see the downturn coming.’”
“Brokers in Stockton are now increasingly offering so-called short sales. Even so, sales are slow to come, leading to annoyed sellers.”
“‘They’re not crazy about us or anybody right now,’ Mr. Godi said. ‘They’ll say, ‘Gee, I lowered the price on my house, why haven’t you sold it?’”
“He added, ‘It’s much better dealing with people if they’re going to make a profit.’”
“Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac can still purchase mortgages and issue securities. But those who want larger mortgages, or cannot make down payments, face a harder burden.”
“Jumbo mortgages are most important in areas with high home prices, most notably on the East and West coasts. ‘In California, it has shut down the purchase market,’ said Jeff Jaye, a mortgage broker in the Bay area. ‘It has shut down the refi market.’”
“Investors made the mistake of assuming that housing prices would continue to rise, said Dwight M. Jaffee, a real estate finance professor at the University of California, Berkeley. ‘I can’t believe these sophisticated guys made this mistake,’ he said. ‘But I would remind you that lots of investors bought dot-com stocks.’”
“He added, ‘When you are an investor, and everybody else is doing the same thing and making money, you often forget to ask the hard question.’”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “For California’s home builders, it has gone from a perfect storm to a pathetic one. Each week, it seems, there is more bad news as potential buyers stay away in droves. A recent wave of discounting has lured some shoppers to subdivisions, where a backlog of unsold dwellings await … something … anything.”
“But the price cuts, ranging from $10,000 to more than $150,000 on $1 million-plus homes, have yet to turn many of the looky-loos into buyers, according to anecdotal information from homebuilding executives.”
“‘This is the first recession (in the housing market) that isn’t being driven by job losses,’ said Steve Delva, president of the South Bay division of Standard Pacific Corp. ‘Somebody called (the housing bubble of 2005-06) a perfect storm of cheap interest rates, a lack of supply and rampant speculation. Then, when the air went out of the bubble, everybody turned back into pumpkins.’”
“Standard Pacific, with headquarters in Irvine, has several projects in Northern California. It reported a $165.9 million loss for the second quarter, which ended June 30.”
“Nearly all of the publicly traded home builders in the country have reported substantial losses this year, including such widely known names in the Northern California market as Toll Bros., Pulte Homes, Centex and KB Homes.”
“As the year has progressed, tens of thousands of families have fallen behind in their payments until the dreaded ‘notices of default’ arrived.”
“With no other choice, they put their nearly new homes up for sale only to discover that a growing glut of other frantic sellers had flooded the market with their distressed properties.”
“As homes sat waiting for buyers who never materialized, prices nose-dived to a point where owners owed far more on their mortgages than they could ever hope to realize on a sale.”
“‘There’s a lack of urgency among people (looking for homes) right now,’ said Mike Forsum, regional president of Taylor Woodrow Homes. ‘Traffic is up … at many of our projects, but I get the feeling that you’ve got the hovering masses waiting for the next big deal before they buy.’”
“As with previous housing slumps, this one seems to be playing out along a well-traveled path, building industry officials say.”
“‘This isn’t going to get better until this unsold inventory gets absorbed,’ said Standard Pacific’s Delva, ‘And this isn’t going to happen until the financing issues are resolved; the smart money has the slump ending in the letter half of next year or some time in 2009.’”
The LA Times. “In the county of Riverside, in the city of Corona, on a street called Plume Grass, there’s a foreclosed house that no one wants to buy. A decade ago it was worth $148,000. That’s what Theodore and Cassandra Judice paid the developer, Beazer Homes, borrowing nearly all of that sum.”
“Life threw some curveballs. In 2000, they refinanced, drawing cash out in exchange for a bigger monthly mortgage. Theodore would marvel at his neighbor’s boats, their swimming pools, their toys. He and Cassandra did some remodeling, getting the patio done, he remembers, was particularly urgent.”
“The couple refinanced again in 2001, 2003 and 2004, borrowing larger sums each time.”
“In September 2005, the Judices borrowed $447,500. Almost immediately after that, they put the house on the market for $480,000. It was time to go: They had drawn so much cash out of their home they couldn’t afford to live there anymore. The ATM had turned into a trap. With no equity cushion, they couldn’t afford to cut their price either.”
“‘They got offers, but they weren’t high enough for them to break even,’ says their agent, Peter Pesek. ‘They wanted to keep waiting for something better.’ It never came; the market had peaked.”
“The couple moved to Austin, Texas, and bought another house. They couldn’t afford both mortgages, so for Plume Grass they tried to negotiate a short sale, an agreement in which the lender accepts less than it is owed. The deal fell through.”
“A notice of default was filed June 9, 2006, making the house one of the first in Corona to enter the foreclosure process in the current downturn.”
“‘We made some bad decisions,’ acknowledges Theodore. ‘No one ever came to our house and forced us to do anything.’ He figures it will take him several years to clean up his credit record.”
“GMAC Mortgage took ownership after the foreclosure. The lender asked Leo Nordine, a veteran foreclosure agent based in Hermosa Beach, to clean up the house and evaluate it for resale.”
“On March 15, Nordine recommended $6,000 in cosmetic work and a low price to get out in front of the market. ‘Don’t overprice,’ he warned.”
“His suggestion: $425,000 for the house as it was, $437,500 if the repairs were done. The lender didn’t authorize the repairs, and stuck a price of $445,000 on the house. No one wanted it.”
“On May 30, Nordine advised reducing to $409,000. GMAC agreed to drop the price, but only to $419,500. Six weeks earlier, that might have done the trick. Not anymore. A week later, Nordine recommended $399,000. The lender didn’t respond.”
“On June 27, he suggested $390,000. Lower the price, he urged yet again: There are three times as many lender-owned homes on the market now as there were a few months ago. On July 31: ‘This is the worst market I’ve ever seen.’ He proposed $385,000.”
“There was no answer. GMAC, like most lenders, has been in turmoil. In late April it said it would fire 700 workers. The asset manager for the Plume Grass house was one of them.”
“To sell the house now, Nordine said late last week, would require a price of $379,000. ‘The banks will wise up after a bit,’ the agent said. ‘I think the fall is going to get really ugly.’”
“A GMAC spokesman said Friday morning that the lender’s goal was to sell all its properties, including the Plume Grass house, for ‘fair market value.’ Several hours later, either wising up or merely responding to the glare of publicity, GMAC sent Nordine an e-mail authorizing him to drop the price to $395,000.”
The Daily News. “Foreclosures and loan portfolio problems continue to grow, troubles that are wearing down Wall Street and spilling into foreign markets. A big question is what the impact will be in California. We’ve already seen a record number of foreclosures in the second quarter, and the threat of a record-breaking third quarter looms.”
“Sales in California have reverted to mid-1990s levels, a down cycle that persisted for most of that decade. Up until last year, credit was so easy that many loan applications were works of fiction. Not a problem, really, because appreciation was still strong, interest rates low and there would be an opportunity refinance out of a toxic loan.”
“Not any more. Now we have a situation in which the last ones into the housing market are the first ones trying to get out.”
“The Internet company Bargain Network found that in July, California had 29,931 properties on the foreclosure path. That’s the most in the nation and a 5 percent increase from June.”
“California is also the nation’s biggest real estate market so being No. 1 isn’t a surprise. California is the country’s fifth-most distressed state, foreclosure-wise. Nevada is the most distressed state followed by Florida, Colorado and Arizona.”
“California leads in another area, too, the most mortgage activity in the nation, including the subprime variety that’s now a vexing problem. For example, last year California led the nation in buyers who opted for payment-option adjustable rate mortgages, commonly known as negative amortization loans. They accounted for 24 percent of all the state’s home loans.”
“Nationwide payment-option ARMs made up 11 percent of home loans. Looks like we’ve got some of the trouble behind us. And more ahead of us, too.”