Tumbling Prices A Real Possibility In California
The Sacramento Bee reports from California. “Sacramento-area home sales ticked up for the second straight month in November. But the excess supply and rising numbers of bank-owned homes continued to push down sales prices. Much of November’s slight sales increase can be traced to a rise in closings of new homes across the capital region, said DataQuick. Home builders reported 88 more closings in November than the previous month.”
“That’s a reflection of sales begun in late summer and early fall, a time when builders like K.Hovnanian boasted 47 sales in one weekend from splashy discounting efforts. But overall sales numbers are still at 1990s levels and prices have returned to 2004 levels across much of the region, DataQuick reported.”
“Sacramento County, where median sales prices of new and existing homes combined are now 18.3 percent below this time last year, is still California’s hardest-hit urban county for declining values.”
“Placer County’s median sales price for existing homes dipped to $382,000 from $400,000 in October. Sales prices in the suburban county are now down nearly 25 percent below their August 2005 peak of $505,000.”
The San Francisco Chronicle. “The Bay Area housing market showed no signs of recovery in November, with sales hobbling along at a two-decade-low pace and buyers still struggling to find mortgages.”
“A total of 5,127 new and existing houses and condos traded hands last month, down 36.2 percent from November 2006, according to DataQuick. That’s the lowest sales count for the month since at least 1988, when the firm began tracking the market. It is the 34th consecutive month of declines.”
The Recordnet. “In California, there were 39,992 foreclosure filings in November, down 21 percent from the previous month but up 108 percent from a year earlier. RealtyTrac said California cities accounted for five of the nation’s top 10 metro foreclosure rates last month.”
“Broker Steve Clark said he hasn’t seen any signs that the foreclosure scene is improving. A lot of people still come into his office hoping to list their houses in hopes of selling to avoid foreclosure, he said. Typically, though, they owe at least $100,000 more on the house than they could get for it, he said.”
“‘We can’t list it,’ he said he tells them. ‘Nobody will buy your home and help you out of this mess.’”
“There have been hardly any sales all this year, anyway, he said, adding that his office mainly handles property management for rental homes - an active scene. ‘I don’t see a change any time soon,’ Clark said. ‘It’s terrible, and I have a hard time seeing where the silver lining is.’”
From ABC 7 News. “Stockton still has the highest foreclosure rate in the country, Solano County is number six. Antioch’s been hit hard too.”
“The signs are everywhere, a lifeless lawn, a neglected tree, a drained hot tub and an empty mailbox. On all too many streets in Antioch, there’s merely a house where there used to be a home. ‘It’s sad, it’s really sad, because I’m sure when these people bought their homes, it was their dream,’ said Sonya Polk.”
“Sonya Polk has lived here four years; long enough to see a once thriving neighborhood turn strangely quiet. ‘It’s not that ‘This is a nice neighborhood, it’s quiet.’ It’s quiet because it’s empty,’ said Polk.”
“According to Realty Trac, last month in Contra Costa County, there were nearly 2,400 new foreclosure filings.”
The Ventura County Star. “Ventura County continued to grow very slowly last year, fueled by a steady increase in births coupled with an influx of foreign immigration that barely neutralized the exodus of residents to other counties and states.”
“The trend, said Bill Watkins, executive director of the UC Santa Barbara Economic Forecast Project, is a reflection of economic reality: high housing prices coupled with fewer opportunities to land a job that pays enough to afford a house.”
“‘Opportunities are declining,’ he said, noting layoffs at the county’s two largest private employers, Amgen Inc. and Countrywide Financial Corp.”
“Bob Schrader, controller at Hilford Moving and Storage in Ventura, said his industry has not benefited by the number of people leaving.”
“‘Under normal circumstances, we have more people moving in than moving out,’ he said. ‘But these aren’t normal circumstances. You’ve now got people just walking away from their homes and taking nothing with them except a few personal possessions.’”
The LA Times. “California’s population continued to grow modestly in the last fiscal year despite a significant exodus of residents to other states, according to a state report released Wednesday.”
“The annual study by the Department of Finance showed that 89,000 more people moved out of California than moved here from elsewhere in the United States. California’s population did grow in fiscal 2007, but the growth rested on births and the arrival of more than 200,000 immigrants from other countries.”
“‘If you’re someone in finance and you haven’t already been laid off…or if you’ve lost your job here and maybe your house, maybe you’re thinking that there are better prospects out there in other states,’ said Howard Roth, chief economist for the Department of Finance.”
“While the state lost many residents during the economic downturn of the 1990s, people had been steadily moving to California from other states since 1999.”
“But once the housing bubble burst, the trend reversed.”
“The story was repeated in Southern California, where every county except Riverside and San Diego saw a decrease in ‘domestic migration.’”
“The slowdown in Inland Empire growth will probably get worse next year as regional housing sales continue to slow, said John Husing, an economist who studies Inland Empire counties.”
“The number of houses sold in Riverside and San Bernardino counties in the first quarter of 2007 was about half the number sold in the first quarter of 2006, he said.”
“‘The slowdown in the housing market attacks the fundamental strength of the Inland economy,’ Husing said. ‘I personally think we’re heading into a recession here.’”
The Voice of San Diego. “The slump that has plagued the San Diego County housing market is beginning to show on the commercial side.”
“The trouble defies the industry mindset, prevalent even up until a few months ago, that commercial and residential real estate share little more than a surname, that the health of the real estate market for apartment investors, offices and industrial space would remain untouched by the housing market’s troubles.”
“‘I think we’d all like to think that the meltdown in the housing market hasn’t affected the commercial side,’ said Kraig Kristofferson, senior VP with CB Richard Ellis. ‘But the reality is people look at real estate in one big basket, often.’”
“National homebuilder Lennar, for example, recently listed 50,000 square feet of its office space for lease to other tenants in order to cut costs, said Jason Hughes, principal with local firm Irving Hughes. And then there are mortgage companies, title companies, escrow companies — going out of business or cutting back on staff, and space, he said.”
“‘It goes on and on,’ Hughes said. ‘Anyone that says that residential is not affecting commercial is nuts, because it simply is. There are a ton of tenants who are in a difficult situation because of the housing market, residential real estate offices are closing their doors. … And that’s happening at the same time as the credit crunch.’”
“With heavy losses sustained by such investors this summer due to soaring defaults on subprime and other mortgages, those investors grew skittish. Some lenders backed by them have stopped funding loans altogether.”
“‘The credit crunch has probably taken out 75 percent of buyers who were out kicking tires a year ago,’ Hughes said.”
“In another subsector of commercial real estate, values are shifting in apartment buildings after years of significant increases in prices from investors looking to convert apartments and sell them as individual condos.”
“Robert Vallera, principal with local firm Commercial Realty Advisers, referred to an apartment property about to close in El Cajon that is selling for ‘perhaps 25 percent below where it would’ve sold two-and-a-half years ago.’”
“‘Apartment prices a few years ago, mid-decade, were primarily based upon condo-conversion economics,’ Vallera said. ‘We’re seeing some properties come on the market now where the prices have made a substantial correction.’”
“‘[Would-be buyers] read the paper just like everybody else,’ said Brandon Keith, another principal with Commercial Realty Advisers. ‘If it’s their first commercial purchase, they maybe think, ‘If housing prices are going down, then maybe commercial prices will, too.’”
From Reuters. “The surge in home foreclosures in California…may help send the state’s home prices tumbling by adding properties to already swollen listings of homes for sale, said John Burns, an Irvine, California consultant to home builders.”
“‘That scenario is a real possibility. Home prices are completely out of line with people’s income,’ Burns said.”
“‘It’s a total buyer’s market,’ he said during a telephone interview with Reuters. ‘There is a tremendous number of homes for sale out there.’”
“Comerica Bank Chief Economist Dana Johnson said in a report this week the state is likely heading into a ‘multiyear period’ marked by home prices lagging national trends.”
“‘Something akin to the experience from 1989 through 1997 may re-emerge,’ he wrote.”
“Johnson noted that earlier this year California’s median home price peaked at 175 percent of the national median, a premium buyers attacked before the recent credit crunch with adjustable-rate mortgages and 100 percent financing.”
“Johnson noted that for two decades before the frantic homes market of the early 2000s, a ratio of California’s median home price and median income held to a narrow range of five to six, indicating affordability. Then speculation and lax lending, especially with subprime loans, sent the ratio soaring to 10.”
“Now only 24 percent of households in California can afford to buy an entry-level home.”
“For affordability to return to California’s housing market, its home prices must fall by at least 30 percent even after recent declines, Johnson said.”
“That is may not be out of the question given the mortgage crunch is sidelining so many prospective buyers while the backlog of homes for sale builds, Burns said: ‘There are very few people who are qualified under today’s underwriting criteria to buy an entry level home.’”